Skip to content

Zinzan Brooke names his dream rugby XV – no room for Carter or McCaw

All Blacks Rugby News
Screenshot 2026-11-17 at 23.10.12
All Blacks legend Zinzan Brooke once picked his ultimate rugby dream team, but there was no room for Dan Carter or Richie McCaw.
The former New Zealand No.8 made some surprising calls when naming his all-time World XV.
Eight All Blacks made the cut, but two of the country's greatest-ever players were nowhere to be seen.
Carter, a two-time Rugby World Cup winner, missed out to Beauden Barrett at fly-half.
McCaw, who captained New Zealand to World Cup glory in 2011 and 2015, was also overlooked.
England legends Jonny Wilkinson and Martin Johnson didn't make the team either.
And Brooke even resisted the temptation to pick himself.

Zinzan Brooke's all-time dream XV

15. Christian Cullen (New Zealand) – One of the finest attacking full-backs the game has seen. Give him an inch and he'd take 50 metres.
14. David Campese (Australia) – The Australian great could turn a match with one moment of magic.
13. Philippe Sella (France) – A wonderful centre who made the difficult stuff look easy.
12. Joe Stanley (New Zealand) – A key figure in the All Blacks side that won the first Rugby World Cup in 1987.
11. Jonah Lomu (New Zealand) – The man who changed rugby forever. His legacy continues today, with his sons following in their father's footsteps.
10. Beauden Barrett (New Zealand) – A huge call. Brooke picks Barrett ahead of Carter and Wilkinson.
9. Gareth Edwards (Wales) – Still regarded by many as the greatest scrum-half ever. He also features in RUCK's ranking of the best No.9s of all time.
1. Os du Randt (South Africa) – A giant of South African rugby who won World Cups 12 years apart.
2. Sean Fitzpatrick (New Zealand) – Tough, relentless and one of the finest captains the All Blacks have produced.
3. Pascal Ondarts (France) – An old-school French prop who never took a backward step.
4. Brodie Retallick (New Zealand) – A brilliant modern lock who could mix the physical stuff with some outrageous handling.
5. John Eales (Australia) – They called him 'Nobody' because nobody was perfect. He wasn't far off.
6. Michael Jones (New Zealand) – One of the most gifted flankers to play the game.
7. Jean-Pierre Rives (France) – A fearless competitor who seemed to spend half his career playing with blood on his shirt.
8. Kieran Read (New Zealand) – Brooke leaves himself out and hands the No.8 shirt to another All Blacks great.

No room for Carter or McCaw

The biggest talking point is undoubtedly the absence of Carter and McCaw.
Carter scored 1,598 points in 112 Tests and helped New Zealand win back-to-back World Cups.
McCaw played 148 times for the All Blacks, captaining them to both titles.
Both have a strong claim to being the greatest players ever to wear the black jersey.
Wilkinson and Johnson aren't bad omissions either.
Wilkinson kicked England to World Cup glory in 2003, while Johnson lifted the trophy as captain.
Brooke's choices are certainly open to debate, although he isn't the only rugby legend to make some surprising selections.
loading

LATEST COMMENTS

Loading