Over the years, rugby union has prided itself on physicality, honesty, and respect — values often cited as what separates it from other sports.
However, the game hasn’t been completely immune to accusations of simulation. A small number of high-profile incidents have seen players criticised for exaggerating contact, appealing theatrically, or attempting to influence referees.
Join the RUCK’s WhatsApp community here and get the latest news sent straight to your messages.
Whether fair or not, these moments tend to stick. They spark debate among fans, pundits, and former players about where the line sits between “selling” a foul and outright diving — and whether rugby is drifting toward behaviour more commonly associated with football.
Despite governing bodies encouraging tougher officiating and the introduction of TMO reviews to clamp down on foul play, the perception of simulation still lingers in certain cases.
As per Scrum Recap, here are some of the game’s most debated “sly” operators — along with a closer look at the incidents behind the claims.
#5. Stuart Hogg
What they said:
“He often overdoes the theatricality to the extent that not even the officials will give him a second look. Look back to the South Africa vs Scotland game a couple years back when he flung himself into the ‘Beast’ just to be laughed off by players and fans around him.”
The incident:
The moment most often referenced came during the 2015 Rugby World Cup clash between Scotland and South Africa. Chasing a kick, Hogg collided with Tendai Mtawarira (“The Beast”) and dramatically appealed for a penalty, suggesting obstruction. Referee Nigel Owens was having none of it, famously telling Hogg to “stay on your feet” and effectively dismissing the appeal in real time — a rare and memorable public reprimand.
That clip quickly went viral and has followed Hogg ever since, often resurfacing in conversations about simulation.
Our verdict:
Hogg played on the edge and was never shy about appealing to officials, but branding him a diver feels harsh. In a career full of fearless counter-attacking and physical bravery, this looks more like an isolated moment that stuck rather than a defining trait.
Fan reaction:
“Tom Daley’s spot in the British Diving team is under threat by Hogg. Excellent call from Owens.”
