Everyone Shares One Complaint About Sir Clive Woodward’s ‘Top 50 Lions’

Rugby News
Wednesday, 16 July 2025 at 21:59
sir clive woodward webinarx40658d95
Former Lions head coach Sir Clive Woodward has taken on the near‑impossible task of ranking the top 50 British & Irish Lions of all time — and yes, it’s just as controversial as you’d expect.
There’s no doubt the list features some of the greatest names in rugby history. But one decision in particular has fans seriously divided.

“Number one had to be Sir Gareth Edwards. Arguably, the greatest rugby player of ALL TIME,” one fan wrote.



RUCK’s Lions content is powered by ISUZU. 

Another added: “Surprised he didn't have Jonny Wilkinson at No.1. It shows how good Gareth Edwards was that second place feels like an insult.”

Woodward himself admits any of his top four could have been No. 1, but when push came to shove, he chose someone he knows inside out from his coaching days.
We’ve rounded up the top 10 from his list below — complete with stats, Woodward’s quotes, and a verdict on each pick.

10. Brian O’Driscoll

Nation: Ireland
Position: Centre
Lions Tours: 2001, 2005 (Captain), 2009, 2013
Test Caps: 8
Test Points: 30

"In 2005, I didn’t have much hesitation in handing him the Lions captaincy. There were plenty of options, but O’Driscoll’s form and leadership for Ireland, combined with his Lions heroics in Australia, made him the obvious choice."

"His famous try against the Wallabies in 2001 sealed his place in the game’s history."

"I loved working with O’Driscoll and when he was the victim of a spear tackle right at the start of the first New Zealand Test in 2005, it sent shockwaves through our camp. It was a reflection of O’Driscoll’s quality that the Lions never really recovered."

Verdict:
A supremely gifted centre and modern great whose 2001 brilliance is etched into Lions folklore. His early injury in 2005 remains one of the great 'what ifs' in Lions history.

9. Alun Wyn Jones

Nation: Wales
Position: Lock
Lions Tours: 2009, 2013, 2017, 2021 (Captain)
Test Caps: 12
Test Points: 0

"Twelve Tests for the Lions, captain in South Africa four years ago, and a modern-day Willie John McBride. Jones set the standard both with Wales and the Lions and it was up to everyone else to follow."

"He won in Australia in 2013 and was a key figure in the drawn New Zealand series of 2017, forming a great partnership with Maro Itoje."

Verdict:
A colossus of the professional era. His consistency, longevity and leadership define the modern Lions lock — an icon of resilience and respect.

8. Sam Warburton

Nation: Wales
Position: Flanker
Lions Tours: 2013 (Captain), 2017 (Captain)
Test Caps: 5
Test Points: 0

"The only man in Lions history to captain the side into at least two Test series and never end up on the losing side."

"He was a brilliant player, but arguably an even better captain. I loved his calm leadership style and the way he empowered the players around him. Today, I like his television punditry too."

Verdict:
A master of quiet authority and tactical acumen. Warburton was the embodiment of modern leadership, guiding the Lions through two unbeaten series with distinction.

7. Barry John

Nation: Wales
Position: Fly-half
Lions Tours: 1968, 1971
Test Caps: 5
Test Points: 30

"Barry scored 188 points in 21 tour games for the Lions, including 190 in 15 games in 1971 when he was dubbed the ‘King’ in New Zealand. It was a deserved moniker."

"He really was that good a player, the sort of back who was worth the admission fee alone."

Verdict:
A short but stunning career defined by magic and mastery. The King of 1971, Barry John remains one of the most mesmerising talents to wear the red jersey.

6. Fran Cotton

Nation: England
Position: Prop
Lions Tours: 1974, 1977, 1980
Test Caps: 4
Test Points: 3

"He was one of the rocks on which the 1974 Test series success was built, anchoring the scrum in South Africa."

"He returned to South Africa as tour manager in 1997, when he was crucial in setting the right tone and atmosphere for the first professional tour."

Verdict:
A stalwart of the front row and a figure of strength both on and off the field. Cotton helped define the character and standards of the Lions across decades.

5. JPR Williams

Nation: Wales
Position: Full-back
Lions Tours: 1971, 1974
Test Caps: 8
Test Points: 3

"If you’re immediately recognisable by your initials, you must have done something right."

"The latter series in South Africa was made for Williams, taking on the Springboks without a backward step."

Verdict:
Fearless, iconic, and endlessly influential. JPR redefined the full-back role and remains a towering presence in Lions lore.

4. Sir Ian McGeechan

Nation: Scotland
Position: Fly-half / Centre
Lions Tours: 1974, 1977 (Player), 1989, 1993, 1997, 2009 (Coach)
Test Caps: 8
Test Points: 3

"‘Geech’ essentially represents the Lions in human form, often referred to as ‘Mr Lions’ or the ‘saviour of the Lions’."

"He sums up what the Lions means and you see that on television even now, when he’s covering the tours with Sky Sports."

Verdict:
A true custodian of Lions tradition. Few have contributed more to the red jersey — as a tactician, mentor, and unshakable believer in what it means to be a Lion.

3. Willie John McBride

Nation: Ireland
Position: Lock
Lions Tours: 1962, 1966, 1968, 1971, 1974 (Captain)
Test Caps: 17
Test Points: 3

"Probably the greatest Lions captain of all-time and the man who has played more games and more Tests for the touring team than anyone else."

"The 1971 and 1974 Lions are the greatest of all-time and McBride was at the heart of both packs."

Verdict:
The ultimate Lions warrior. His leadership in 1974 became the blueprint for all captains to follow. An enduring symbol of courage and class.

2. Sir Gareth Edwards

Nation: Wales
Position: Scrum-half
Lions Tours: 1968, 1971, 1974
Test Caps: 10
Test Points: 3

"I loved Edwards. He just misses out on being No 1 and I appreciate the view of those who would say he should be top of the list."

"A true Lions icon and one of the best players to ever do it."

Verdict:
Poetry in motion and the greatest to ever pass, kick or run in a Lions jersey. If this list were about pure playing greatness — and not just leadership — Gareth Edwards would be first without debate.

1. Martin Johnson

Nation: England
Position: Lock
Lions Tours: 1993, 1997 (Captain), 2001 (Captain)
Test Caps: 8
Test Points: 0

"His leadership was on another level. He was the McBride of the professional era and the first man to captain the Lions twice."

"Some might say there is some bias involved here, but Johnson, for me, stands above the rest."

Verdict:
A totemic leader and granite-like second row. Johnson’s Lions legacy is sealed by his fierce competitive edge and the respect he commanded — but even he may tip his cap to Edwards’ genius.
loading

Loading