Greig Laidlaw on stacked five man shortlist to replace Scotland boss Gregor Townsend
Rugby NewsSunday, 23 November 2025 at 16:43
Despite recently putting pen to paper on a contract extension, rumblings from north of the border suggest Gregor Townsend’s reign as Scotland head coach may be under threat.
Townsend’s decision to take on a second role with Austrian-owned Red Bull hasn’t gone down well with fans, even if the move is touted as a potential boost for Scottish rugby investment.
As Rugby Pass’ Neil Fissler notes, “the knives are out for Townsend in Scotland,” a mood mirrored by the boos that met the squad last weekend. Yet the coach remained resolute at yesterday’s pre-match press conference. “I’m here to address anything,” he declared.
Below, we run through the five leading contenders to take over at Murrayfield should Townsend’s tenure come to an early close.
? The top contenders to replace Gregor Townsend
? Joe Schmidt – The mastermind behind Ireland’s golden era
If Scotland want a proven winner, Schmidt ticks every box.
During his time in charge of Ireland (2013–2019), he delivered a Grand Slam, three Six Nations titles, a historic win over New Zealand, and a series victory in Australia.
He turned Ireland into a global juggernaut.
More recently, he helped New Zealand reach the 2023 World Cup final, showcasing once again his elite tactical brain.
Known for his meticulous planning and game management, Schmidt, who will depart the Wallabies next year, could bring a new level of precision and ruthlessness to Scotland.
Family commitments make this one unlikely, but there is no doubt he'd be a top candidate if he pit his name into the miz.
? Vern Cotter – The man who rebuilt Scotland once before
If the SRU want to go back to basics—and back to success—Cotter is your man.
The big Kiwi coached Scotland from 2014 to 2017, lifting the team from also-rans to serious contenders.
He guided them to a World Cup quarter-final in 2015, brought in a tough, disciplined edge, and gave fans unforgettable moments—like that 2017 Calcutta Cup win.
Currently in charge of Fiji, Cotter is a respected international operator with a gritty, forward-led approach. He doesn’t do fluff. Just results.
? Stuart Lancaster – The rebuilder turned title-winner
After a brutal exit as England head coach in 2015, Lancaster went back to the drawing board.
He rebuilt his coaching credentials at Leinster, masterminding their 2018 Champions Cup victory and multiple Pro14 titles, helping develop stars like James Ryan, Garry Ringrose, and Jordan Larmour.
Now the boss at Racing 92, Lancaster has evolved. He blends structure with attacking flair—just the kind of balance Scotland might need post-Townsend.
And crucially, he knows how to build a culture.
? Franco Smith – The tactical genius behind Glasgow’s rise
The form man in Scottish rugby right now.
Smith has transformed the Glasgow Warriors into one of the most exciting sides in the URC, lifting the 2024 Challenge Cup and winning plaudits across Europe.
His philosophy? High-tempo, heads-up rugby—ideal for a Scotland side packed with attacking threats.
A former Italy head coach, Smith has international pedigree and deep knowledge of Scottish rugby already. He could be the natural successor, keeping the momentum going with minimal disruption.
?? Greig Laidlaw – The dark horse with leadership pedigree
He’s a legend in a Scotland shirt—76 caps, a former captain, and the heartbeat of the team for nearly a decade.
Now starting out in coaching over in Japan, Laidlaw is learning his trade the hard way. He’s an outsider for now, but don’t rule him out.
Few understand Scottish rugby like he does, and his leadership on and off the pitch was second to none.
He’s a long-term project, but one the SRU will be keeping tabs on.
So, what’s next?
Townsend is still under contract. But the pressure is growing.
Whether it’s Schmidt’s polish, Cotter’s steel, or Smith’s spark—Scotland have serious options.
But as Beattie reminded fans: changing the head coach doesn’t always bring instant success.
“Would you rather be watching England under Borthwick or Wales under Gatland? That’s the trade-off,” he said.
Who do you want in charge of Scotland?
TRENDING
LATEST NEWS
LATEST COMMENTS
- Jordie Barrett over Damian de Allende is far from being correct. The hype around Dupont is also overreaching, he's probably 4th in the world and has been since the 2023 WC. He also avoids certain matchups which is strange. The rest of the list is pretty good apart from minor subjective biases.JasonMarlow16-09-2026
Loading