Steve Borthwick's Three Biggest Selection Headaches this Autumn

With England's depth of talent, several selection dilemmas loom large. Here are three of the most significant.

With Alex Mitchell likely ruled out with a neck injury, Borthwick has a tricky decision between the experienced Ben Spencer and the dynamic Harry Randall at scrum-half.

Bath captain Spencer, with his tactical awareness and superior game management, offers control and consistency. His crisp distribution and kicking game make him a safer bet, particularly in tight games.

On the other hand, Randall brings electrifying pace and creativity to the breakdown, thriving in open play. His high tempo can disrupt defences, but he sometimes lacks the calm needed in high-pressure scenarios. Borthwick must weigh the need for control versus the desire for attacking flair.

Verdict: Ben Spencer

In the second row, the competition between Ollie Chessum and George Martin is heating up. Chessum’s versatility and athleticism have seen him become a mainstay in the England pack, but George Martin’s physicality and work rate have impressed in recent Premiership games.

Chessum is a line-out specialist, and his mobility around the park gives him the edge in open play. Martin, however, adds bulk and aggression, vital for the arm-wrestles in the tight five. Borthwick will have to decide between Chessum’s dynamism and Martin’s raw power.

Verdict: Ollie Chessum

The battle at fly-half poses a challenge. Fin Smith’s composed game management has impressed, but Marcus Smith remains a mercurial talent with game-breaking abilities.

Fin Smith offers control, whereas Marcus thrives on unpredictability. The choice will depend on whether Borthwick prioritizes stability or moments of magic.

Verdict: Marcus Smith