Three surprise absences from England squad leave fans questioning Borthwick's choices

Despite strong domestic form and proven international pedigree, three major stars have been left out.

Few players have done more to demand selection than Adam Radwan. The electric winger has been in scintillating form for Leicester Tigers, recently scoring a brace in their win over Sale. His pace and finishing have made him one of the Premiership’s deadliest attackers, yet he has once again been left out by Steve Borthwick.

It’s understood that Radwan’s omission comes down to selection balance, with England opting to invest in the next generation. Rising Saracens star Noah Caluori, who impressed during a recent training camp, has earned his first call-up at Radwan’s expense.

While Borthwick praised Radwan’s club form, he hinted that tactical versatility and aerial presence were deciding factors.

Fans, however, have voiced frustration online, describing his exclusion as “inexplicable” given England’s ongoing search for cutting edge on the wings. Radwan will likely feature again soon — but for now, his omission is one of the most controversial talking points of the Autumn selection.

The exclusion of Tom Willis has reignited debate around England’s eligibility rules. The 26-year-old No. 8 has been a standout performer for Saracens and a reliable presence in England’s back row since the 2025 Six Nations.

Yet, his recent decision to join Bordeaux Bègles in France’s Top 14 has rendered him ineligible for international duty under the Rugby Football Union’s long-standing policy barring overseas-based players.

Willis’s absence is a major blow to Steve Borthwick’s plans, particularly with fellow back-rowers Ben Curry, Ted Hill, and Alex Dombrandt all injured. Known for his relentless work rate, physicality, and breakdown dominance, Willis was widely expected to anchor England’s pack this Autumn.

Borthwick acknowledged the loss, admitting that while the door remains open for a potential future return, England must focus on players available for the full World Cup cycle.

The decision underscores the ongoing tension between individual career choices and national selection policy — and for many fans, it feels like another case of the rules hurting England more than they help.

Perhaps the most surprising omission of all is Owen Farrell. England’s former captain and talisman, with over 100 caps to his name, remains one of the country’s most influential players.

Despite returning to Saracens and featuring regularly in the Premiership, Farrell has once again been left out of the national setup.

Steve Borthwick confirmed the fly-half was “not considered for selection,” citing ongoing efforts to give other players opportunities in the pivotal playmaking roles. Insiders suggest the omission is part of England’s longer-term rebuild, with Fin Smith and Marcus Smith now seen as the preferred 10 options heading into the next World Cup cycle.

Farrell’s absence leaves a notable leadership gap within the squad. His competitive edge, defensive organisation, and game management have defined England’s identity for over a decade. Though Borthwick insists “the door is never closed,” fans are beginning to question whether Farrell’s international career is quietly being phased out.

For many, it’s hard to imagine an England side without him — but the Autumn series will show whether this new generation is ready to fill his boots.