Skip to content

World Rugby make Malcolm Marx ban decision after footage emerges

Springboks Rugby News
Screenshot 2026-11-20 at 09.17.52
Springboks hooker Malcolm Marx will escape a ban following South Africa’s controversial 21-19 defeat to France in the Nations Championship.
Footage emerged earlier this week of an alleged punch involving France captain Antoine Dupont during the final play in Paris.
Having watched the footage several times, I believe the incident warranted disciplinary action.
However, Planet Rugby journalist Jared Wright has confirmed that the citing window has now closed, meaning Marx will avoid a suspension.

World Rugby left with questions to answer

As reported by RUCK on Thursday, footage appears to show Marx swinging a clenched fist towards Dupont.
Under World Rugby Law 9.12, striking an opponent is an act of foul play.
In my opinion, there was more than enough evidence to warrant a disciplinary hearing.
Instead, rugby’s disciplinary system looks like a courtroom that has locked its doors before the evidence has arrived.
How can that possibly be right?
World Rugby regularly talks about its commitment to player safety. Allowing potential foul play to go unexamined because of an administrative deadline hardly reinforces that message.

Rassie Erasmus will be absolute box office

Remarkably, Jasper Wiese and Rassie Erasmus have both been banned following events surrounding the defeat in Paris, yet Marx remains available.
Erasmus, who received a six-match suspension, has responded by announcing his own live watchalong for Saturday’s clash against Ireland.
We’ll certainly be muting the ITV commentary at RUCK and listening to the Springboks boss instead.
Whatever your opinion of Erasmus, it promises to be absolute box office.
As for Marx, the hooker is free to feature in Dublin as South Africa chase a place in the Nations Championship Grand Final.
I’m not suggesting Marx should be banned without a hearing. Quite the opposite.
The fact we seemingly cannot have one is precisely the problem.

Build your ultimate rugby XV

Think you know your rugby? Take on RUCK’s Ultimate Rugby Draft, combining legends of the game with modern-day superstars to build the strongest possible XV.
Can you beat the top score on our global leaderboard?
The citing deadline is now attributed to Jared Wright's reporting, while the judgement on the alleged punch is explicitly presented as your opinion rather than an established disciplinary finding.
loading

LATEST COMMENTS

Loading