Skip to content

All Blacks player ratings vs England: Four 3/10 horror shows as New Zealand humiliated

All Blacks Rugby News
imago1086162996h
The All Blacks were torn apart at Twickenham as England ran riot to claim a humiliating 37-12 victory over Dave Rennie's side.
New Zealand were second best from the opening whistle. Their attack offered almost nothing, their discipline was poor and England repeatedly punched holes in their defence.
Ben Earl was sensational, making 30 carries and 138 metres, while Ollie Chessum caused havoc at the lineout.
The All Blacks managed just three visits to England's 22. They were outplayed, outmuscled and, at times, made to look like a second-tier international side.
The defensive statistics were particularly ugly.
Jordie Barrett, Damian McKenzie, Cam Roigard and Fletcher Newell all missed four tackles. George Bower added another three after coming off the bench.
It was an afternoon several established internationals will want to forget.
Here are our brutally honest All Blacks player ratings.

All Blacks player ratings vs England

1. Ethan de Groot – 7/10

One of the few All Blacks who can hold his head high. Powered over from close range for New Zealand's opening try and showed some much-needed fight. Deserved better from those around him.

2. Codie Taylor (c) – 5/10

Started brightly with a crucial breakdown turnover and a powerful carry before De Groot's try. Unfortunately, New Zealand's lineout became a complete mess. Losing two throws shortly after half-time was simply unacceptable. Not the captain's finest afternoon.

3. Fletcher Newell – 4/10

Held his own reasonably well at scrum time, but four missed tackles tell a different story. England repeatedly won the physical exchanges and Newell offered far too little resistance. A disappointing afternoon.

4. Scott Barrett – 4/10

Put in plenty of defensive work, but where was the leadership? New Zealand desperately needed someone to grab the game by the scruff of the neck. Instead, Barrett was flattened by a monstrous Chessum tackle late on, coughing up possession. That rather summed up his afternoon.

5. Fabian Holland – 6/10

One of the few forwards who genuinely earned his wages. Made 20 tackles and 13 carries, while also producing an important offload in the build-up to Beauden Barrett's try. Worked tirelessly despite the chaos unfolding around him.

6. Tupou Vaa'i – 4/10

A frustrating afternoon. Coughed up possession when New Zealand finally appeared to be building something and struggled to make much impression with ball in hand. England's forwards won the physical battle far too easily.

7. Peter Lakai – 6/10

At least he turned up for the fight. Produced an excellent breakdown steal in the first half when England were threatening again. One of the few All Blacks who didn't look completely overwhelmed by the occasion.

8. Wallace Sititi – 6/10

Worked himself into the ground defensively, making 21 tackles. Unfortunately, there was precious little opportunity to show his attacking qualities. One of the few players who can reasonably argue he did his job.

9. Cam Roigard – 3/10

Four missed tackles, a costly knock-on and an embarrassing attempt to stop Ben Earl for England's third try. His excellent break and perfectly timed pass for Beauden Barrett's try offered some redemption. Not nearly enough to rescue a horror show.

10. Damian McKenzie – 3/10

An absolute shocker by his standards. Four missed tackles, a cynical off-the-ball challenge on Seb Atkinson and a missed conversion. Lucky not to see yellow for the Atkinson incident. New Zealand desperately needed their playmaker to take control, but he was a liability defensively.

11. Josh Moorby – 3/10

Was he even playing? Barely featured as an attacking threat and spent much of the afternoon watching England run riot. Admittedly, New Zealand's forwards gave him almost nothing to work with, but this was an anonymous display.

12. Jordie Barrett – 3/10

Four missed tackles from one of New Zealand's most experienced players. Made early handling errors, conceded a needless penalty and was completely overshadowed by Seb Atkinson. Nowhere near good enough.

13. Anton Lienert-Brown – 4/10

Offered some resistance defensively, but where was the attacking threat? England's midfield repeatedly found space while New Zealand's looked painfully predictable. A forgettable performance from an experienced international.

14. Will Jordan – 4/10

Couldn't prevent Ollie Chessum from powering over for England's bonus-point try. Admittedly, stopping a rampaging forward from close range was a thankless assignment. His afternoon ended early, but he had already struggled to make an impact.

15. Beauden Barrett – 6/10

Marked his 150th Test with a beautifully taken try, running a superb support line onto Roigard's pass. One of New Zealand's rare moments of genuine quality. Unfortunately, it was little more than a consolation on a day he will want to forget.

All Blacks replacements – 4/10

New Zealand's bench offered precious little resistance as England continued to dominate. George Bower missed three tackles, while Pasilio Tosi conceded a scrum penalty as the hosts tightened their grip. Anton Segner was a rare bright spot with an excellent lineout steal, but the arrivals of Richie Mo'unga, Cortez Ratima and Rieko Ioane did little to change the contest. By then, the damage was already done.

Rate the All Blacks players yourself

Think you could do better than our ratings? Now it's your turn.
Rate every All Blacks player out of five stars using our interactive fan ratings tool below, then compare your scores with RUCK's verdict after the final whistle.

RUCK Player Ratings Key

  • 10/10 – World-class. A performance for the ages.
  • 9/10 – Outstanding. One of the best on the pitch.
  • 8/10 – Excellent. A major influence on the game.
  • 7/10 – Very good. Plenty to admire.
  • 6/10 – Solid. Did the job without standing out.
  • 5/10 – Average. Some good, some bad.
  • 4/10 – Poor. Below international standard.
  • 3/10 – Dreadful. A game to forget.
  • 2/10 – Horror show. A complete liability.
  • 1/10 – Catastrophic. Almost everything went wrong.
  • 0/10 – Historically bad. Reserved for the truly extraordinary.
loading

LATEST COMMENTS

Loading