Former England scrum-half Danny Care has voiced his disapproval of the number of foreign-born stars selected for the British & Irish Lions tour to Australia.
RUCK’s Lions content is powered by ISUZU.
Speaking on the
BBC Rugby Union Weekly podcast, Care didn’t hold back as he questioned the inclusion of southern hemisphere-born players who qualified for their nations through residency.
? “It doesn’t sit that well with me that some of these… both your starting wingers are going to be lads that never, ever once in their childhood or even their mid-20s dreamt of wearing a red Lions jersey.”
With the likes of James Lowe, Duhan van der Merwe, and Jamison Gibson-Park all potentially lining up in red, Care admitted the situation is within the rules, but far from ideal.
?️ “It is what it is, it’s the rules… but it just doesn’t [feel right]. I think there’s a lot of people that feel the same but can’t say it.”
Inside Centre Debate Sparks Backlash
When RUCK asked the simple question – “Who should start at inside centre for the Lions?” – the replies were unexpectedly fierce.
Both suggested options were foreign-born, and that didn’t sit well with a vocal minority of traditionalists.
One furious fan raged:
“How’s about finding British Born Players to play for the British Lions?”
Another fumed:
“Neither are British,” keeping their argument short and salty.
Pot, Kettle, Pacific?
Another supporter took a swing at the hypocrisy, writing:
“I remember years back when UK fans mocked NZ for their ‘Pacific-picked’ players. Now look – there’s always a Kiwi, Fijian, Samoan or Tongan in every European team!”
Not Everyone’s Having It
But not all fans agreed with the outrage. One passionate rugby lover clapped back:
“Really ridiculous how people have an issue with foreign people who have the right to play for another nation.
They are legally eligible! It’s no different to someone becoming a citizen of another country.
This makes for better, more competitive rugby – and that’s what we want, right?
If you can’t handle it, go support football instead.”
RUCK’s Take? No Issue Here
Let’s be clear – RUCK doesn’t have a problem with it. If a player is eligible and has earned their spot through form, commitment, and quality performances, we’re all for them pulling on the red jersey.
The game has changed. So has the world. Rugby is better when it’s inclusive, competitive, and stacked with world-class talent – wherever they were born.
So, Who’s “Foreign-Born” Anyway?
In total, 9 of Farrell’s 38-man squad were born overseas. Here’s the breakdown:
1. Pierre Schoeman (Scotland) ??
2. Jamison Gibson‑Park (Ireland) ??
- Born: 23 Feb 1992 on Great Barrier Island, New Zealand
- Position: Scrum-half
- Club: Leinster (from 2016), over 130 appearances
- International: Qualified by residency, debuted 2020; earned Irish citizenship late 2023; 33 caps
- Personal: Married to Patti; father to three children
3. Marcus Smith (England) ??
- Born: 14 Feb 1999 in Manila, Philippines
- Position: Fly-half / Fullback
- Club: Harlequins since 2017 – 172 appearances, 1,563 points
- Background: Born to a Filipina mother and British father; formative years in Philippines and Singapore
4. Bundee Aki (Ireland) ??
- Born: 7 Apr 1990 in Auckland, New Zealand
- Position: Centre
- Club: Connacht (since 2014), plus Chiefs and Counties Manukau previously
- International: Irish-qualified by residency; over 66 caps and Irish citizenship granted mid-2020s
5. Sione Tuipulotu (Scotland) ??
- Born: 12 Feb 1997 in Victoria, Australia
- Position: Centre / Wing
- Club: Glasgow Warriors since 2021; earlier stints with Melbourne Rebels & in Japan
- International: Scotland-qualified via grandmother; debuted 2021; current Scotland captain & Lions pick 2025
6. James Lowe (Ireland) ??
- Born: 8 Jul 1992 in New Zealand
- Position: Wing
- Club: Leinster; previously Auckland & Chiefs
- International: Qualified by residency; citizenship in 2025
7. Mack Hansen (Ireland) ??
- Born: 27 Mar 1998 in Canberra, Australia
- Position: Wing / Fullback
- Club: Connacht since 2021; current Connacht Player of the Year (2022)
- International: Ireland-qualified via mother; debuted in 2022 Six Nations
8. Duhan van der Merwe (Scotland) ??
- Born: 4 Jun 1995 in George, South Africa
- Position: Wing
- Club: Edinburgh since 2017; also played for Montpellier & Bulls; prolific try-scorer
- International: Scotland-qualified via residency; debuted Oct 2020
9. Finlay Bealham (Ireland) ??
- Born: 9 Oct 1991 in Canberra, Australia
- Position: Prop (tight- and loosehead)
- Club: Connacht since 2014 – over 200 appearances; key in 2016 Pro12 title
- International: Ireland-qualified via grandmother; debuted 2016; 41 caps, two Six Nations titles (2023, 2024), Grand Slam 2023
- Lions Call-Up: Selected for 2025 Lions tour – replacing Zander Fagerson
EDITORS PICKS:
- The British & Irish Lions starting XV to face Argentina, Marcus Smith starts
- Gloucester confirm signing of Leinster wing ahead of next season
- England confirms they’ve called up Racing 92 star for summer tests
- Lions star releases statement confirming he will miss 2025 tour
- 2003 World Cup winners son gets first England call-up from Steve Borthwick
RUGBY QUIZ: QUIZ: Can you name the 2013 British & Irish Lions squad?
Think you’re a true rugby nut? It's time to put your Lions knowledge to the test.
12 years have passed since Warren Gatland’s men roared to a famous series win over Australia, but how well do you really remember the iconic 2013 British & Irish Lions squad?
From legendary leaders to surprise selections, we’ve lined up every player from that unforgettable tour. All you have to do is name them. No pressure, right?
Take the quiz below and prove your rugby brain still bites.
? Scroll down and get cracking – how many can you get without cheating?
