The end of France’s clash with Argentina descended into confusion, leaving referee Hollie Davidson facing a lengthy delay as officials tried to resolve a series of issues surrounding a late scrum.
France secured top spot in the northern hemisphere standings with a convincing 45-17 victory over Los Pumas.
However, the closing stages were overshadowed by a bizarre five-minute stoppage involving substitutions, disciplinary procedures and a communication breakdown between the officials.
The confusion centred on Argentina’s depleted front row and the rules surrounding replacements when a team has players temporarily or permanently off the pitch.
Los Pumas were down to 13 men, with captain Julian Montoya serving a yellow card and Mayco Vivas having received a red card.
Davidson initially called for an uncontested scrum, with Argentina unable to field a full front row.
Replacement hooker Facundo Bosch had originally entered the game with Montoya off, but with the Argentina captain still serving his yellow card, questions remained over the composition of the pack.
Davidson then consulted her fellow officials to establish whether any of Argentina’s absent front-row players had been removed for a head injury assessment (HIA).
Because the departure is due to a head injury rather than foul play or a lack of planning, a team with a HIA is not penalised by losing an extra player on top of the temporary replacement.
Joe Sclavi was eventually confirmed as having left the field for an HIA, although the language barrier appeared to complicate communication throughout the process.
Argentina lock Guido Petti was then caught up in the confusion, coming on and going back off after receiving conflicting instructions from the officials.
Eventually, the officials reached a decision.
Because Sclavi was taken off with a HIA, it meant that Petti was able to come on the pitch as his replacement, with the scrum being uncontested due to there not being enough front rows.
However, there was still time for one final twist. Louis Bielle-Biarrey scored directly from the resulting uncontested scrum, bringing the bizarre sequence of events to an end.
Ultimately, despite the initial confusion, Davidson did come to the correct conclusion and explained the rules very effectively.













