All Blacks legend Dan Carter has settled the score, regarding who is the greatest fly half of all time. The man considered by many rugby fans as the GOAT of the game, was presented with a handful of rugby’s most iconic number 10s, whom he whittled down to decide the overall best to wear the jersey.
Join the RUCK’s WhatsApp community here and get the latest news sent straight to your messages.
In an original video from French rugby news outlet Midi Olimpique RugbyRama, Carter picked between the likes of Owen Farrell, Ronan O’Gara, himself and Jonny Wilkinson, to decide the undisputed winner of the endless debate.
After much deliberation, Carter ranked England’s 2003 Rugby World Cup hero Jonny Wilkinson as the greatest ever fly half, and you can watch his decision process in the video below.
EDITORS PICKS:
- Popular referee Nigel Owens named rugby’s ultimate hardman
- Former England Rugby Star Feared Dead After Car Swept Away in Flood
- Sir Clive thought fly-half could be better than Wilkinson never fulfilled potential
- Glamorous South Africa Physio Accused of ‘Pitch Dark Arts’ Departs
- Six Nations fanbases ranked: Who tops the table and who falls flat?
Jonny Wilkinson Named His Top 5 Fly-Halves in Rugby History
The 2003 Rugby World Cup hero, who secured England’s first title with his now-iconic drop goal, highlighted the immense responsibility of wearing the No.10 jersey.
“This is the key position for any World Cup-winning team,” Wilkinson emphasised.
“You need guys that are going to lead and continue to do so right to the final seconds when it gets very, very tough. I can’t just pick one.”
Book VIP Six Nations Packages, Hospitality and Premium Experiences from Seat Unique.
1. Michael Lynagh (Australia)
A tactical genius who redefined playmaking, Lynagh was the fulcrum of the Wallabies’ backline for over a decade. Debuting in 1984, he became Australia’s all-time top scorer, amassing 1,048 points in 72 internationals—a record that still stands. Lynagh’s leadership was pivotal to Australia’s triumph in the 1991 Rugby World Cup, where he orchestrated a flawless campaign.
Did you know? Lynagh’s son, Louis, plays for Italy and scored on his debut against South Africa in 2024.
2. Dan Carter (New Zealand)
The poster boy of modern rugby, Carter combined flair, precision, and sheer dominance to redefine the fly-half role. A three-time World Player of the Year (2005, 2012, 2015), he amassed an unmatched 1,598 international points. His near-faultless performance in the 2015 Rugby World Cup final cemented his status as rugby royalty.
Did you know? Carter once turned down a $10 million NFL offer to remain loyal to the All Blacks.
3. Joel Stransky (South Africa)
Stransky’s boots carried the weight of a nation. His 1995 Rugby World Cup-winning drop goal in extra time remains the most celebrated moment in Springbok history. Known for his composure under pressure, he scored 150 points in 22 Tests for South Africa—a feat remarkable for the era.
Did you know? Stransky, fluent in five languages, was once tipped to pursue a political career in South Africa.
4. Stephen Larkham (Australia)
Larkham wasn’t just a fly-half; he was a magician. Originally a fullback, he transitioned to No.10 and became the creative genius behind Australia’s golden era. His 48-metre drop goal in the 1999 World Cup semi-final remains one of rugby’s greatest moments. Larkham played 102 internationals, winning two Tri-Nations titles and the 1999 World Cup.
Did you know? Larkham’s laser eye surgery in 2000 was sponsored by a South African fan impressed by his performances.
5. Grant Fox (New Zealand)
Grant Fox may not have been a flashy player, but his unmatched kicking accuracy made him indispensable. The All Blacks’ metronome at the 1987 Rugby World Cup, Fox scored a staggering 136 points in six matches, setting a tournament record that lasted 16 years.
Did you know? Fox once hit 25 consecutive penalties in a single training session, earning the nickname “The Iceman.”
Rugby World Cup-winning captains – can you name them all?
Out of these exceptional leaders, some have claimed the title just once, while others have done so on multiple occasions. Captains from nations such as New Zealand, Australia, England, and South Africa are part of the exclusive list of multiple-time champions.
We challenge you to identify all Rugby World Cup-winning captains across the tournament’s history spanning 10 editions.
