Nigel Owens slams World Rugby's latest law change

byRugby Rucker

Former international referee Nigel Owens has voiced reservations about one of Super Rugby Pacific’s latest law trials, suggesting the adjustment could create uneven decision-making across the competition.

Sanzaar recently confirmed that under Law 8.3, referees will no longer be obligated to issue a yellow card when awarding a penalty try. Instead, officials will decide whether any additional punishment is necessary.

Join RUCK’s Instagram broadcast channel
and get the latest rugby news straight to your phone.

Owens, speaking on Whistle Watch, admitted the topic has long been a talking point between himself and fellow former Test referee Wayne Barnes.

“Wayne Barnes and I have always had a good debate about this,” Owens said. “Barnes had the same view on it as Super Rugby that it shouldn’t have to be a double whammy, but I don’t know.

“What they are doing here now is technically rewarding a negative act. So a player now will decide, unless I go out there and deliberately knock this ball forward or I don’t deliberately throw myself and collapse this maul, they are going to score.

“What is making them think twice is that we’re going to be down to 14 men as well for 10 minutes. Now think about it. If I don’t deliberately knock this ball or fall down there or if I don’t take down this maul illegally, they’re probably going to score.”

While referees still have the authority to send a player to the sin bin, Owens believes the reliance on discretion could lead to inconsistent outcomes.

“Yes but then you’re opening up the inconsistency,” he said. “So what you can have then is one maul going down and giving a yellow card and a penalty try, another one going down and giving just a penalty try.

“For me, this should be a deterrent. What you have now is a player thinking, ‘I’m going to risk it here, the referee may not give a penalty try, and even if he does, we’re still going to be at 15 men’.

“So, I’m not sure what the point of this is. As it is now, I think it’s very consistent. You know, if you commit an act of foul play that prevents a probable try, you go to the bin. So, there’s no inconsistency if they can identify the player.”

Rugby World Cup 2027 Full Draw: England and Wales meet again

The expanded 24-team tournament will be played across Australia from 1 October 2027, with six pools of four teams and a new round-of-16 knockout phase. With fixtures and venues now confirmed by World Rugby, attention quickly turns to how each group will unfold.

Pool A — New Zealand, Australia (H), Chile, Hong Kong China

Group summary

Pool A features tournament hosts Australia and three-time champions New Zealand, making it one of the headline groups of the opening phase. Chile and Hong Kong China will be targeting historic results, while the trans-Tasman clash between Australia and New Zealand is expected to be one of the most watched pool matches of the tournament.

Fixtures

1 October 2027 — Australia vs Hong Kong China
Perth Stadium, Perth
2 October 2027 — New Zealand vs Chile
Perth Stadium, Perth
9 October 2027 — New Zealand vs Australia
Stadium Australia, Sydney
9 October 2027 — Chile vs Hong Kong China
North Queensland Stadium, Townsville
15 October 2027 — New Zealand vs Hong Kong China
Docklands Stadium, Melbourne
16 October 2027 — Australia vs Chile
Brisbane Stadium, Brisbane

Pool B — South Africa, Italy, Georgia, Romania

Group summary

Defending champions South Africa headline Pool B and begin their campaign against Italy. Georgia continue to establish themselves as a consistent World Cup presence, while Romania return aiming to challenge for third place and possible qualification via rankings.

Fixtures

3 October 2027 — South Africa vs Italy
Adelaide Oval, Adelaide
3 October 2027 — Georgia vs Romania
North Queensland Stadium, Townsville
10 October 2027 — South Africa vs Georgia
Brisbane Stadium, Brisbane
11 October 2027 — Italy vs Romania
Sydney Football Stadium, Sydney
17 October 2027 — Italy vs Georgia
Newcastle Stadium, Newcastle
17 October 2027 — South Africa vs Romania
Perth Stadium, Perth

Pool C — Argentina, Fiji, Spain, Canada

Group summary

Pool C blends South American consistency with Pacific flair. Argentina enter as favourites, while Fiji’s attacking threat makes them dangerous opponents for any side. Spain return to the World Cup looking to make an impact, and Canada continue their rebuilding process.

Fixtures

3 October 2027 — Argentina vs Canada
Brisbane Stadium, Brisbane
4 October 2027 — Fiji vs Spain
Newcastle Stadium, Newcastle
10 October 2027 — Fiji vs Canada
Adelaide Oval, Adelaide
10 October 2027 — Argentina vs Spain
Docklands Stadium, Melbourne
16 October 2027 — Argentina vs Fiji
Adelaide Oval, Adelaide
17 October 2027 — Spain vs Canada
North Queensland Stadium, Townsville

Pool D — Ireland, Scotland, Uruguay, Portugal

Group summary

Ireland and Scotland lead Pool D in what shapes as a tightly contested group. Uruguay and Portugal bring speed and tactical variety, with qualification likely to be decided by fine margins, discipline, and bonus points.

Fixtures

3 October 2027 — Scotland vs Uruguay
Docklands Stadium, Melbourne
4 October 2027 — Ireland vs Portugal
Sydney Football Stadium, Sydney
10 October 2027 — Ireland vs Scotland
Perth Stadium, Perth
11 October 2027 — Uruguay vs Portugal
Newcastle Stadium, Newcastle
17 October 2027 — Ireland vs Uruguay
Docklands Stadium, Melbourne
17 October 2027 — Scotland vs Portugal
Brisbane Stadium, Brisbane

Pool E — France, Japan, United States, Samoa

Group summary

France headline Pool E after reaching the previous final, with Japan expected to challenge strongly for second place. Samoa and the United States provide physicality and athleticism, making this one of the more unpredictable groups.

Fixtures

2 October 2027 — France vs United States
Docklands Stadium, Melbourne
3 October 2027 — Japan vs Samoa
Newcastle Stadium, Newcastle
9 October 2027 — United States vs Samoa
Perth Stadium, Perth
9 October 2027 — France vs Japan
Brisbane Stadium, Brisbane
15 October 2027 — Japan vs United States
Adelaide Oval, Adelaide
17 October 2027 — France vs Samoa
Sydney Football Stadium, Sydney

Pool F — England, Wales, Tonga, Zimbabwe

Group summary

Pool F is defined by the renewed rivalry between England and Wales, who will meet in one of the final pool fixtures in Sydney. Tonga’s physical style and Zimbabwe’s return to the World Cup add further intrigue, with third place potentially enough to reach the knockout stage depending on rankings.