‘Abject’: Three England players to drop for the World Cup final — and who should replace them

Back from concussion that kept her out of the quarter-final, Kildunne’s pace broke France open either side of half-time. Yet England’s display was far from polished. Errors in the first half handed France territory and possession, leaving the score delicately poised at 7–5 at the break.

A stronger second-half performance restored order, with hooker Amy Cokayne finishing from a trademark driving maul before Abbie Ward crossed from close range. Still, Ashton Gate saw a mixed display, with head coach John Mitchell expected to weigh up selection changes before next weekend’s showpiece final.

"Far better in the second half after an abject display in the first. Acted like a vortex for England’s attack in the red zone."— Telegraph

Replacement: Emily Scarratt (35, ~118 caps) – England’s all-time leading points scorer and a five-time World Cup participant. Centre/full-back with unmatched game management and composure in high-pressure moments. Currently returning from injury but still a proven big-game presence.

"Quick thinking with the tap for the third try. Never felt like she had her forwards organised like she wanted them and there were communication issues with Heard." — Telegraph

Replacement: Lucy Packer (25, ~30 caps) – Harlequins scrum-half, known for fast service and sharp box-kicking. Smaller in stature but adds tempo and attacking zip around the breakdown. Has become increasingly central to England’s game plan in 2024–25.

"Industrious without being particularly eye-catching. A tally of three carries is not what you would expect of a No 8." — Telegraph

Replacement: Marlie Packer (36, ~108 caps) – Veteran flanker, Saracens captain, and England co-captain. A relentless tackler with huge breakdown presence, consistently delivers in the biggest matches. Brings leadership, physicality, and a hard edge missing at times against France.

"Failed to grab the game by the scruff of the neck. Kicking was generally on the money but could not get England on the front foot in attack in the first half." — Telegraph

Replacement: Holly Aitchison (27, ~40 caps) – Versatile fly-half/centre with strong distribution and running lines. Offers more attacking creativity than Harrison, and has been impactful when introduced from the bench. Recently recovered from injury, bringing both flair and tactical flexibility.