All Blacks player ratings vs Sharks: Rugby's Greatest Rivalry

Tuesday, 11 August 2026 at 19:50

byCharlie Elliott

All Blacks player ratings from a convincing 54-0 win against the Sharks in the second game of the Rugby's Greatest Rivalry tour.

Join RUCK’s Instagram broadcast channel

Following a remarkable pre-match, which saw Ma'a Nonu do his own Haka as a response to the All Blacks, the Sharks started strongly in the rain at Kings Park, but struggled to turn possession into points.

The All Blacks grew into the contest, with Fehi Fineanganofo scoring his first try in black. Damian McKenzie then crossed after a TMO check, giving New Zealand a 14-0 lead heading into half-time.

Caleb Clarke extended the lead just five minutes into the second half, and from there, Dave Rennie's side took complete control.

Fineanganofo got a second, before Jordie Barrett, Kyle Preston, Timoci Tavatavanawai and Sam Darry all crossed as the All Blacks produced some scintillating rugby, while keeping the Sharks scoreless.

Scroll down for All Blacks player ratings vs Sharks.

Sharks: 0

All Blacks: 54

Tries: Fehi Fineanganofo (19', 53'), Damian McKenzie (29'), Caleb Clarke (45'), Jordie Barrett (60'), Kyle Preston (63'), Timoci Tavatavanawai (70'), Sam Darry (76')
Conversions: Ruben Love (20', 30', 46', 54', 61', 63', 76')

All Blacks player ratings vs Sharks

15 Damian McKenzie — 7

The experienced fullback showed flashes of quality in difficult conditions, scoring in the corner after a burst of pace, although he was close to being tackled into touch. Before that, he was also guilty of a costly knock-on with the try line beckoning.

His evening was cut short after just 33 minutes after playing through an early ankle injury, and fans will be hoping that it is nothing serious.

14 Fehi Fineanganofo — 8

Making his first All Blacks start, the winger showed his finishing quality with two tries and an assist for McKenzie. He was tenacious in the air and showed his killer try instinct that led to 17 tries in Super Rugby last season.

A hugely impressive outing that will surely only strengthen the All Blacks' desire to keep him away from a move to Newcastle Red Bulls.

13 Quinn Tupaea — 8

It is easy to see why he was named Super Rugby Player of the Season. His intelligent play, powerful carries and superb offloading were outstanding, including a brilliant break to set up Kyle Preston’s try.

12 Jordie Barrett — 8

Barrett was effective with his boot throughout, relieving pressure and repeatedly finding space out wide to accelerate attacks.

His clever kicking helped create chances for Fineanganofo and Caleb Clarke, with a neat kick through sparking the chaos for the fourth try finished by Fineanganofo following an earlier kick out wide to assist the winger's first try.

He also showed his pace to finish strongly in the corner.

11 Caleb Clarke — 7

A quieter outing than some of his fellow backs, with limited opportunities to make an impact with his carries. He was reliable in the air and took his chance well, finishing in the corner. A solid performance without ever really dominating the game.

10 Ruben Love — 8

Love underlined his excellent Hurricanes form with a superb all-round display. His early 50/22 showcased his game management, while he repeatedly found space in the backfield and linked well with the attack.

He was outstanding off the tee, converting six of his first six, almost exclusively from the touchline, before finally missing his seventh attempt.

Beyond the tee, Love was incredibly lively and always played on the front foot, helping to kick the ball on for Fineanganofo's second try.

With Beauden Barrett struggling for form, Love has made a compelling case to start at 10.

9 Kyle Preston — 8

Given an opportunity following Cam Roigard’s injury, Preston has taken it with both hands. His electric tap-and-go produced a remarkable break of about 70 metres, beating defenders before kicking into space.

He kept the tempo high around the ruck and capped his display with a deserved try, showing exactly why he is worth a closer look.

1 Ethan de Groot — 6

Ethan de Groot had a solid but unremarkable outing at scrum time against Vincent Koch and worked hard defensively, making eight tackles before coming off after 54 minutes.

2 Asafo Aumua — 6

Aumua was busy defensively and came close to scoring, but his lineout throwing let him down overall. Made seven tackles before coming off after 54 minutes. It was a tough set-piece for him given the conditions, so he can't be criticised too greatly.

3 Fletcher Newell — 6

The scrum battle was fairly even, although a costly penalty was conceded on the Sharks’ five-metre line. Defensively, he worked hard and made seven tackles before coming off after 54 minutes.

4 Josh Lord — 7

After an early penalty conceded the breakdown, the towering lock grew into the game with strong tackling and disruptive work at the lineout. He applied pressure at the breakdown, while slick hands produced the assist for Fineanganofo’s try.

5 Sam Darry — 8

Darry continued to strengthen his case as a reliable Test option after another promising display. He tackled well early, was good at the breakdown and carried effectively, although a couple of penalties let him down. A deserved late try capped a strong performance.

6 Tupou Vaa’i — 6

Quietly effective throughout, Vaa’i made some important tackles while his side was under pressure and impressed with his work at the ruck. He did not dominate proceedings but went about his work efficiently.

7 Luke Jacobson — 7

The All Blacks captain led from the front with a strong defensive effort, making double-digit tackles in the first half. His distribution was equally impressive, producing a superb offload to Sititi before delivering a brilliant basketball-style assist for Barrett.

8 Wallace Sititi — 7

A quiet but effective first half saw him contribute positively at the breakdown and keep the ruck speed high. Sititi grew into the game, producing a superb pass for Clarke’s try before coming off after 59 minutes.