"Blacklisted" - Four player who won’t play for England again under Borthwick

England’s recent Six Nations reset — highlighted by the bold decision to drop George Ford from the matchday squad after defeats to Ireland and Scotland — felt like more than a short-term reaction. It looked like a clear line being drawn.

Selection windows are now auditions for Australia 2027. And for some players, the message seems increasingly blunt: they’re no longer part of the plan.

Here are five players who look unlikely to wear an England shirt again while Borthwick remains in charge.

The omission of Ford wasn’t subtle.

After back-to-back defeats to Ireland and Scotland, Borthwick didn’t rotate his senior fly-half — he removed him entirely. With Fin Smith handed the reins and the coaching staff doubling down on a refreshed backline, it signalled a strategic shift rather than a temporary tweak.

Ford has been one of England’s most dependable operators over the last decade. But international rugby moves fast, and World Cup cycles move faster. At 30+, he now looks like yesterday’s solution to tomorrow’s problem in the eyes of the current regime.

Could he return in a crisis? Possibly. But coaches rarely pivot away from an established No.10 this decisively unless they’re planning long-term.

Right now, it feels like the page has turned.

Watch the Guinness Six Nations at your local Greene King sports pub.

The situation surrounding Tom Willis is far more straightforward.

After deciding to move abroad, Willis effectively removed himself from the England equation under RFU selection policy. Borthwick publicly stated that England would invest time in players who will be part of the 2027 World Cup campaign — and confirmed Willis is not in that group.

That’s as clear as it gets.

Regardless of form, availability remains king in Test rugby. Once a player falls outside the strategic pathway, reversals are rare.

For Willis, the door doesn’t look ajar — it looks shut.

Few England stories have been as frustrating as Zach Mercer.

A standout at club level, Mercer has repeatedly found himself on the outside of England’s plans. After being told he wasn’t part of Borthwick’s vision, he openly admitted he felt “done” with England and needed to step away for his own mental well-being.

He later returned to France — a move that, under current selection rules, makes a recall even less likely.

The reality? Mercer doesn’t fit the mould Borthwick appears to prefer at No.8 — a more defensively dominant, collision-heavy profile.

With policy and preference both working against him, his England chapter appears finished.

On paper, Ollie Hassell-Collins ticks boxes.

Size. Power. Finishing ability.

Yet despite strong club form, he’s remained stuck on two caps with little indication he’s climbing back into contention.

Wing is one of the most unforgiving positions in Test rugby. Once a hierarchy forms, it’s difficult to break back in — especially when coaches appear to have stylistic preferences locked in.

The longer Hassell-Collins remains outside the squad, the clearer the message becomes.

Sometimes absence says everything.

In the storied history of Rugby's Greatest Championship, exceptional leaders have emerged—warriors of various forms, be they agile half-backs, towering second rows, or fearless flankers.

Our latest quiz invites you to identify those who have captained their nations to Guinness Six Nations glory. It's worth noting that in certain instances, there may be multiple captains from the same year due to factors such as injuries and rotation.

Surnames only will be accepted.