England legend tells Steve Borthwick to replace Maro Itoje as captain

Former England fly-half and Times columnist Stuart Barnes has even suggested time could be running out for Maro Itoje as skipper, arguing the lock still hasn’t fully mastered the art of managing referees at Test level.

So, who should get the armband? Here's the four man shortlist.

Calm, composed and virtually undroppable, Itoje remains the favourite to lead England into the summer. His influence within the squad is enormous, and his consistency at Test level makes him the safest option.

Trusted by team-mates and coaches

Leads through actions rather than noise

A long-term captaincy option

The concern? As Barnes pointed out, England still need more from Itoje when it comes to managing officials and controlling momentum during difficult periods.

If Steve Borthwick is thinking beyond this tour, though, Itoje still looks the standout candidate.

If England simply want the best captain for the next three Tests, Lawes has a compelling case. Back in the England frame after his spell in France, he remains one of the most respected figures in the game.

Proven Test captain

Sets standards immediately

Brings calm in high-pressure moments

Lawes commands instant respect and has already shown he can lead England through brutal Test matches. The downside is obvious: at this stage of his career, he’s a short-term answer rather than the future of the team.

Passionate, confrontational and unapologetically vocal, Genge would bring edge and emotion to the role — qualities England have lacked at times in recent years.

Drives intensity across the squad

Strong personality and leadership voice

Connects naturally with younger players

But there is a risk attached. Genge’s combative style does not always land well with referees, and international captaincy often requires diplomacy as much as aggression.

Chessum’s rise over the past two seasons has been impossible to ignore. Still only developing as a Test player, the Leicester forward already looks like one of England’s most trusted leaders on the pitch.

Leads through physicality and work-rate

Highly respected within the squad

Represents England’s next generation

Chessum may not yet have the profile of Itoje or Lawes, but his influence is growing rapidly. He brings intensity without losing composure and has the kind of presence coaches value in tough away environments.

Handing him the captaincy now might feel early — but England could see him as a future long-term leader worth accelerating.