England XV to play against Scotland: Maro Itoje returns

The hosts, meanwhile, are searching for answers after a bruising 18–15 defeat to Italy in Rome, a result that has only heightened the stakes in Edinburgh.

With form, selection and intent all under the microscope, here’s how we think England will line up for a Calcutta Cup clash that suddenly feels pivotal for both sides.

Scotland tend to attack England in the air, and fortunately for Steve Borthwick he has one of the best fullbacks in the world under the high ball. Steward should, and almost certainly will, start.

Another player who is extremely strong in the air. Roebuck looks set to retain his place after starting against Wales.

Freeman is still learning the ropes at outside centre, but there is plenty to be excited about. It would be a surprise if he was not selected again, such is the faith Borthwick has shown in him so far.

In another life, Dingwall could have been wearing a Scotland shirt due to his eligibility. He has developed into England’s go-to inside centre thanks to his consistency. He links play superbly and elevates those around him.

With Immanuel Feyi-Waboso expected to miss the rest of the Six Nations and Arundell scoring a hat-trick against Wales, it would be very difficult to leave the Bath winger out. There are questions about what he offers beyond tries, but he is a dangerous finisher who can create something from nothing.

Player of the Match against Wales and therefore impossible to drop. He oozes class and remains a constant playmaking threat, underpinned by excellent game intelligence.

The standout option at scrum-half by a clear margin. He will not be dropped, and rightly so.

Some fans may want him used off the bench to add impact later on, but at a venue like Murrayfield the priority should be a strong start to quieten the crowd. Genge is England’s best loosehead and should start.

Experience is vital in games like this, and George has it in abundance.

Clearly ahead of the other tighthead options available to England. He deserves to start unless his power is specifically being saved for the bench.

When fully fit, he is the first name on the teamsheet. After coming off the bench against Wales, despite picking up a yellow card within seconds, he should be ready to start. It is harsh on Alex Coles, but it highlights England’s depth at lock.

A huge physical presence who adds so much to the side. Chessum will deservedly start in the second row.

Pepper is building an impressive Test résumé and has delivered every time he has pulled on an England shirt so far. A top talent who is unlikely to be dropped after a strong showing against Wales.

An absolute monster in defence. Borthwick prefers starting Underhill and bringing Tom Curry off the bench. If it is not broken, do not fix it.

Virtually undroppable. Earl contributes everywhere, combining outstanding defensive work with genuine attacking threat, highlighted by his move into the centres during the Wales match.