England's 2025 Six Nations Players Ranked From Best to Worst

Sunday, 16 March 2025 at 08:00

byRugby Rucker

The 2025 Six Nations campaign was a mixed bag for England, with standout performances from some players and struggles for others.

Join RUCK's Instagram broadcast channel and get the latest rugby news straight to your phone.

Based on match ratings across the tournament, here’s how each player fared, ranked from best to worst.

1. Ben Curry – 7.5

The back-rower emerged as England’s most consistent performer, delivering a standout display against Wales. His high work rate and strong defensive presence made him invaluable.

2. Tom Curry – 7.3

Battling through injury in some games, Curry still managed to be a key figure in England’s pack. His try-scoring effort against Italy and his breakdown work cemented his place among England’s best.

3. Maro Itoje – 7.0

A pillar of consistency in the second row, Itoje’s physicality and leadership ensured England’s defensive line remained solid throughout the competition.

4. Tommy Freeman – 6.9

Freeman's cohesion with his club teammates made him a reliable option in England’s backline. His four tries in four appearances have put him firmly in contention for a Lions spot.

5. Fin Smith – 6.9

His goal-kicking was almost immaculate, and his game management improved as the tournament progressed. Smith’s performance against Wales highlighted his growing confidence at fly-half.

6. Ellis Genge – 6.9

The loosehead prop provided his trademark physicality in attack and scrummaging stability. His leadership and passion were evident, despite some frustrating moments with referees.

7. Ollie Chessum – 6.9

A man-of-the-match performance against Italy was the highlight of Chessum’s campaign. His powerful carrying and set-piece dominance proved crucial.

Decent but Inconsistent – Solid Efforts with Room for Improvement

8. Fraser Dingwall – 6.8

A solid presence in England’s midfield, Dingwall provided key defensive contributions. His 7.5 rating against Wales showed his growing influence.

9. Will Stuart – 6.8

The tighthead prop showed surprising agility for a front-rower, especially in the build-up to Marcus Smith’s try. However, some scrummaging issues prevented him from ranking higher.is growing influence.

10. Jamie George – 6.7

Reaching his 100th cap during the tournament, George was a reliable figure at hooker. His passing skills added an extra dimension to England’s attack, though his missed tackle against Italy was a rare lapse.

11. Chandler Cunningham-South – 6.6

The back-rower showed glimpses of his physicality and potential but remains a work in progress.

12. Ben Earl – 6.6

England’s primary ball carrier for much of the tournament, Earl had a mixed campaign. A strong display against Wales boosted his rating, but injuries hampered his overall impact.

13. Elliot Daly – 6.6

A versatile presence in the backline, Daly adapted well to different roles but lacked standout moments.

14. Luke Cowan-Dickie – 6.6

An impact substitute for most of the tournament, Cowan-Dickie provided strong carrying and set-piece stability when called upon.

Decent but Inconsistent – Solid Efforts with Room for Improvement

15. Alex Mitchell – 6.4

After a slow start, Mitchell improved as the tournament progressed. His attacking instincts were on display against Italy, but some box-kicking issues remained.

16. Tom Willis – 6.4

A strong start against Italy showcased his ball-carrying power, but he faded as the tournament progressed.

17. Joe Heyes – 6.3

An unspectacular but solid campaign for Heyes, who filled in when needed.

18. Henry Slade – 6.2

A disappointing campaign for Slade, who struggled to influence games in the way he has in past tournaments.

19. Marcus Smith – 6.1

A frustrating campaign for Smith, who struggled for consistency. His strong finish against Wales was a reminder of his talent, but he was often overshadowed by Fin Smith at fly-half.

20. Ollie Sleightholme – 6.0

His raw speed was a huge asset, and his finishing ability was evident in his brace against Italy. However, defensive vulnerabilities on the wing were a concern.

21. Fin Baxter – 5.8

A mixed tournament for the young prop, who showed promise but struggled at times against more experienced opposition.

Underperformers – Struggled to Make an Impact

22. Cadan Murley – 5.5

Limited opportunities for Murley, who struggled to make a real impact.

23. Theo Dan – 5.5

Like Murley, Dan’s impact was minimal, and he will hope for better opportunities in the future.

24. Jack Van Poortvliet – N/A

Limited playing time meant it was difficult to fairly assess his performances.

Can you name every England Rugby captain of the professional era?

From the early days of professionalism to the modern era, England has seen a host of legendary captains wearing the armband.

Whether it's the grit of Will Carling in the 90s, the tactical brilliance of Martin Johnson, or the fearless leadership of Owen Farrell, this quiz will challenge even the most dedicated fans.

Think you can name them all? Grab your boots and let's see how well you know the men who led England into battle on the world stage!

Rugby Ranked