Skip to content

Five winners and five losers from a bonkers Nations Championship weekend

Rugby News
All Blacks viral gesture-2
The Nations Championship delivered another extraordinary weekend, with Wales making history, England running riot and two rugby giants suffering painful defeats.
South Africa lost in Paris. New Zealand were stunned in Cardiff. And Eddie Jones probably wishes he'd booked a different flight to London.
There were heroes, villains and a few reputations left in the changing rooms.
Here are RUCK's five biggest winners and losers from the weekend.

WINNERS

1. Wales

Seventy-three years. Thirty-four straight defeats. One unforgettable afternoon.
Wales finally ended their extraordinary wait for victory over New Zealand, beating the All Blacks 35-28 in Cardiff.
Steve Tandy's side were magnificent.
They made an astonishing 346 tackles in their historic victory, which suggests someone forgot to tell them possession was allowed.
Dafydd Jenkins made 38 of them. His shoulders might need a fortnight in Tenerife.
For a nation desperate for something to celebrate, this was enormous.
And for once, Welsh rugby fans can open social media without immediately regretting it.

2. Will Joseph (England)

Five tries. FIVE.
Joseph treated Japan's defence like the self-checkout at Tesco. Every time he went through, nobody stopped him.
The winger equalled England's record for tries in a single Test as Steve Borthwick's side ran out 78-15 winners.
Not bad for someone making his first international appearance since 2022.
His remarkable display earned him 10/10 in RUCK's England player ratings.
With competition for places fierce, Joseph has given Borthwick a selection headache.
The sort every England coach dreams of having.

3. Antoine Dupont (France)

Apparently, being the world's best scrum-half wasn't enough.
France had a fly-half crisis, so Fabien Galthié did what any sensible coach would do.
He handed the number ten shirt to Antoine Dupont.
The result? A historic 21-19 victory over South Africa.
France ended a 21-year wait to beat the Springboks on home soil, with Dupont helping steer them through a frantic contest.
Scrum-half. Fly-half. At this rate, he'll be covering tighthead by Christmas.

4. James Botham (Wales)

The surname is famous. The performance was even better.
Botham was everywhere against New Zealand, throwing himself into tackles like someone had insulted his family.
He was named Player of the Match as Wales finally ended their 73-year wait for victory over the All Blacks.
His performance was rewarded with 9/10 in RUCK's Wales player ratings.
And with fatherhood just around the corner, it's shaping up to be quite a week.
Although after surviving 80 minutes against New Zealand, he might find the sleepless nights a slightly different challenge.

5. Argentina

Not every victory needs fireworks.
Argentina ground out a hard-fought 19-14 win over Italy in Genoa.
It wasn't pretty. In fact, there were moments when watching paint dry might have offered more attacking ambition.
But Los Pumas found a way to win.
And after an inconsistent campaign, they'll happily take the points.
France are next. The paint might need to dry considerably faster.

LOSERS

1. Beauden Barrett (New Zealand)

This wasn't how the script was supposed to go.
Barrett captained New Zealand for the first time in his 149th Test.
Unfortunately, he also became the first All Blacks captain to lose against Wales since 1953.
That's quite a record to inherit on your first day in charge.
The two-time World Rugby Player of the Year struggled to influence proceedings as Wales produced a defensive masterclass.
He was among five players handed 4/10 in RUCK's All Blacks player ratings.
A day that should have ended with champagne probably finished with a very quiet flight home.

2. Eddie Jones (Japan)

Welcome back to Twickenham, Eddie.
Unfortunately, England weren't feeling particularly hospitable.
Jones watched his Japan side concede 12 tries in a humiliating 78-15 defeat.
Will Joseph helped himself to five, while England repeatedly tore through a defence that appeared to have left its tackling instructions at Heathrow.
The former England boss has never been short of confidence.
But even Eddie might struggle to find a positive spin on this one.
At least the weather was nice. Probably.

3. Jasper Wiese (South Africa)

One moment of madness changed everything.
Wiese's dangerous clear-out against France earned him a 20-minute red card and left South Africa facing an enormous challenge.
The Springboks battled back brilliantly, but ultimately fell short by two points.
That's the sort of score usually reserved for someone who turns up at the wrong stadium.
For a player of his experience, it was a costly mistake.

4. Rassie Erasmus (South Africa)

Even rugby's most celebrated coaches have difficult weekends.
Erasmus watched his Springboks fall 21-7 behind in Paris before mounting a remarkable second-half fightback.
South Africa dominated the scrum and nearly rescued the result despite Wiese's dismissal.
But Manie Libbok's missed conversion left them two points short.
The defeat also dealt a major blow to their Nations Championship Grand Final hopes.
Rassie won't panic.
Although we wouldn't be surprised if a few laptops were opened and several hundred spreadsheets updated before breakfast.

5. Australia

Another week. Another defeat.
Australia arrived at Murrayfield looking to bounce back from their heavy loss to England.
Instead, Scotland edged them 15-12 in another frustrating afternoon for the Wallabies.
Max Jorgensen's late try offered hope, but the visitors couldn't complete the comeback.
There were encouraging moments.
Unfortunately, encouraging moments don't appear in the win column.
At this point, Australian rugby fans might be considering taking up cricket.
Then again, perhaps not.

🏉 Think you can build a better XV?

You've seen the weekend's biggest winners and losers. Now it's your turn to pick the stars.
Take on RUCK's Ultimate Rugby Draft. Build your dream XV, use your lifelines wisely and see if you can top the leaderboard.
loading

LATEST COMMENTS

Loading