Rugby transfer expert Neil Fissler has compiled another list of the biggest transfer flops in rugby history, featuring several prominent names.
Join the RUCK’s WhatsApp community here and get the latest news sent straight to your messages.
Here, we examine four of the most notable transfer flops from the list and provide RUCK's verdict.
Check out the full list here.
James Haskell, Wasps – Northampton Saints 2018
Fissler wrote: "Marmite back row Haskell signed for Saints because he wanted to extend his international career, but it was a case of the spirit being willing but the flesh being weak. Recurring ankle and toe problems restricted him to just five appearances, and he announced that he was retiring when his contract ended."
RUCK verdict: This signing initially appeared odd and ultimately proved to be a failure. Although he was an incredible player at his peak, a combination of wear and tear along with injuries prevented him from reaching his best during his tenure at Franklin's Gardens.
Zinzan Brooke, Auckland – Harlequins 2000
Fissler wrote: "Brooke is one of the best No.8s to ever play the game and was signed by cash-strapped Premiership strugglers on a £200,000 as a player-coach, but his best days were clearly behind him when he arrived in South London and out of his depth. He quit the club in January 2001."
RUCK verdict: Too young to remember
Richie Gray, Glasgow Warriors – Sale Sharks 2012
Fissler wrote: "Collins became the sixth All Black to join the Pro D2 champions after they were promoted to the Top 14. He signed a big-money three-year deal but walked out after a season to move to the Ospreys after only making a modest impact."
RUCK verdict: Although Collins never fully fired for Toulon, calling him a flop seems a little harsh.
Richie Gray, Glasgow Warriors – Sale Sharks 2012
Fissler wrote: "Scotland lock Gray was signed by Sale on a three-year deal amid much fanfare, hailing him as their ‘marquee’ signing. However, despite being a talisman for his country and winning selection for the 2013 Lions tour, he left the North-West for Castres a year later after failing to make an impact."
RUCK verdict: "This signing had every Sale fan very excited with the Scottish powerhouse penning a three-year contract. However, the giant Scot would only stay for one season, playing 16 underwhelming matches, scoring one try before joining French club Castres. Never had such a big man, done so little."












