"Costly mistake" - Henry Pollock given brutal player rating after Lions defeat against Argentina

RUCK’s Lions content is powered by ISUZU.

But this time? The heroics didn’t quite hit the mark. A solid heart, no doubt, but the Lions needed more than passion; they needed precision.

If Pollock’s night summed up the whole squad’s vibe, it was this: lots of hustle, plenty of guts, but far too much fancy footwork when what was really called for was just to plow straight through the middle. Sometimes simple is better, folks.

The head honcho didn’t sugarcoat it—this “disconnected” Lions performance has left plenty of lessons to learn before they pack their bags for Australia. That Friday 28-24 loss to Argentina? A wake-up call wrapped in a warning label.

The ratings? Not exactly headline material. Pollock landed at the lower end compared to his mates but hey, it’s a debut — lots to learn and plenty of time to fight for a test spot come next month.

Balls 510: “Missed Albornoz in the build-up to Cordero’s try.” Ouch.

Flo Rugby 5/10: “Big cheers on the bench hype, but that missed tackle when Los Pumas broke away? Not great. On the bright side, a neat carry on the left and he was always sniffing out work, despite being well marked.”

Rugby Pass 5/10: “Pumped and ready but no fireworks this time. Solid around the breakdown, no nerves on debut.”

JOE 5.5/10: “Looked dangerous but that missed tackle leading to an Argie try was costly.”

So, Henry’s first Lions outing wasn’t flawless, but he’s got the tools—and a good dose of grit—to make the next one count.

RUCK actually gave Pollock a 7/10. Deputy Editor Tom Sansom wrote: "The youngest Lion in the squad, Pollock put aside his duties of taking care of Bil the teddy to make his Lions debut. Received a solid ovation off the bench and was immediately involved with the ball in hand. Unafraid to test the waters of life as a Lion with a few involvements.:

Planet Rugby 4/10: "Did brilliantly wiggle through the tackles of Joaquin Oviedo and Juan Martin González but split the ball with the line begging. His lineout throws were wayward which severely disrupted the Lions’ flow. He was part of an excellent scrummaging effort, though."

Rugby Pass 5/10: "A fumble cost him the opening try of the 2025 Lions series off a Lions catch and drive. A few too many lineout howlers from the Cornishman, his Bluetooth connection with Itoje looking a tad unstable."

JOE 5/10: "An error-strewn performance. Dropped the ball over the line in the first half."

Rugby Pass 5/10: "A mixed bag from big Dewie. A couple of promising inside cuts opened his account, but the defensive ring rust was there to see, having very little recent rugby under his belt.

"Got beaten with an Ignacio Mendy inside step for Los Pumas’ opening five-pointer and was somewhat at fault for Los Pumas’ score just before halftime. Always drew defensive attention and made plenty of metres after contact."

JOE 5.5: "Made an awesome break in the first half, but from then on pretty much nothing went right for the Scot. Looked very dodgy, weak in the air, and a prime target to attack."

Telegraph 5/10: "Understandably rusty in his first game for almost three months. Finished the first period by losing possession, leading to a Pumas try, and was quiet in the second. Had started promisingly, stepping off his left to carve open the Pumas."

Flo Rugby 4/10: "Outside of a few early runs, the Scottish winger had a tough first outing. His defensive position exposed the Lions' backfield. In the air, he couldn’t quite get to grips with the high ball,s whilst his one-on-one tackling left a lot to be desired."

BALLS 5/10: "Superb line break, on six minutes, but missed a pass that would have put Mitchell away. Costly error after he was tackled led to Argentina try before the break. Not great under the high ball. An iffy game."

The Irish Times 5/10: "He was a mixed bag in the first half, hitting rucks and a great one-handed pass to Tommy Freeman early on. Was an early threat but was turned over going forward for the Albornoz try before half-time."

BALLS 5/10: "Hefty tackle, close to his own line, shut down try-scoring opportunity for Argentina. Some bright moments but too many were followed by errors. His decision to pressure Tomas Albornoz back-fired when he and Pollock were easily evaded and Argentina counter-attacked to score. Shelled an easy Furlong pass."

Flo Rugby 5.5/10: "Started the fixture strong and got through plenty of work with 12 tackles, 9 carries and a turnover. Unlike his top-line performances, he could never quite find that key impact moment, which would disappoint him."

Flo Rugby 5.5/10: "Started the fixture strong and got through plenty of work with 12 tackles, 9 carries and a turnover. Unlike his top-line performances, he could never quite find that key impact moment, which would disappoint him."

Rugby Pass 5/10: "Scrappy enough for the Harlequin. Opened his 2025 Lions’ account with a poor kick chase and miss tackle and didn’t look terribly comfortable in the air either.

"Saw a bit of ball but was proved a limited counter-attacking threat. Didn’t force the game but did his best to remain involved from the back. Overall, an evening to forget."

The Irish Times 5/10: "Scrambled well for a kicked through ball at the end of the first halfbut wasn’t always solid under the high kicks. Caught out of position and didn’t read the threat when Santiago Cordero scored his second-half try."

Flo Rugby 5/10: "A truly frustrating evening for the England playmaker, who was ultra busy, had some flashes of pure brilliance, but was ultimately brutally exposed by the Pumas' kicking game. Unable to compete consistently in the air and getting caught out of position in the backfield highlighted why flyhalf remains his best position.

"The challenge for him will be whether he can work his way onto the bench as the back-up ten or even challenge for the starting position. With both Blair Kinghorn and Hugo Keenan in the squad, it is tough to envisage Smith getting the nod in the 15 shirt against a potent Wallabies kicking game."

Balls 510: "Missed Albornoz in the lead-up to the Cordero try."

Flo Rugby: "Hyping himself and his teammates up as he came off the bench, the electric young backrow did not have the impact he hoped for. Missing a key tackle as Los Pumas raced away was a big black mark on his evening. On the positive side of things, he had a nice carry on the left-hand side of the pitch, which made some good yards. he was always looking for work and was clearly well-marked by Los Pumas, thus opening a bit of space for those around him."

Rugby Pass 5/10: "Looked pumped on the sidelines but struggled to deliver any highlight reel stuff on this occasion. Active around the breakdown and certainly showed no signs of being overawed on Lions debut."

Join RUCK’s Instagram broadcast channel and get the latest rugby news straight to your phone.

Let’s see if you can nail this quiz and prove you’re a true rugby expert. Ready? Let’s go!