Ireland fans want France game replayed after 'shocking decisions'
Rugby NewsFriday, 06 February 2026 at 11:46
Ireland were left seething after a string of highly questionable refereeing calls during their 36-14 defeat against France, with Karl Dickson firmly in the firing line.
Watch the Guinness Six Nations at your local Greene King sports pub.
The controversy began early, as France’s opening try appeared to stem from a blatant forward pass, a decision that left Irish players incredulous.
Matters only got worse when the hosts’ second try was allowed to stand despite what looked like a clear knock-on in the build-up. Both moments were waved through, fuelling frustration on and off the pitch.
Discipline also proved a major talking point. Antoine Dupont was fortunate to avoid a yellow card after repeated infringements that consistently disrupted Ireland’s rhythm.
The most glaring example came shortly after Ireland crossed for their second try, when Dupont escaped punishment for what many felt was a deliberate knock-on while attempting an ‘intercept’.
The confusion peaked late on in the game. Jonathan Danty Moefana went unpunished for a high tackle with no wrap, in a passage of play where Ireland believed Ronan Kelleher had scored. Even Dickson seemed unsure of events, admitting over the referee mic that he had “no idea what I just saw”.
For Ireland, it was a night where the officiating proved just as costly as anything France produced.
POLL:
EDITORS PICKS:
- Four Ireland changes Andy Farrell must make after France defeat
- Six Nations pundit Ronan O’Gara handed lenghty ban
- “Overhyped” – One Ireland Player Targeted by Fans After Loss Against France
- “Cardiac event” – Uini Atonio health update after second operation
- Bundee Aki breaks his silence on his Ireland future
"Utterly woeful" - Five Ireland players who flopped against France
While France dazzled in attack, this was also an evening that brutally exposed individual Irish shortcomings — and several players endured nights to forget.
Here are five Ireland players who flopped against Les Bleus.
1 Dan Sheehan
Rock-solid at the set-piece, Sheehan delivered flawless lineout throws in difficult conditions but struggled to impose himself in open play. With Ireland badly needing go-forward and physical punch, his usually devastating carrying threat was effectively neutralised by a well-drilled French defence.
Ratings
- Rugby Pass: 5
- Planet Rugby: 5
- BALLS: 4
- FloRugby 5
Comments
FLORUGBY: "Finishing with five carries and four tackles underlined how little influence he was able to have. It was a night where circumstances limited his impact rather than a lack of effort."
BALLS: “Threw a perfect lineout despite greasy conditions in Paris. But was a bit of a non-factor in open play as Ireland cried out for some barnstorming Sheehan carries.”
Planet Rugby: “The basics were solid enough, with his lineout work absolute pinpoint, but he’s certainly not been at his best since suffering that ACL injury in July 2024.”
Rugby Pass: “Struggled to get into the game. Ireland’s lineout functioned reasonably well and Sheehan deserves credit for his role in that. Teams are seemingly getting a lot better at neutralising his running threat.”
2 Sam Prendergast
A night that exposed both Prendergast’s attacking promise and his defensive frailties. While he showed flashes of skill and improved after the break, France repeatedly targeted his reluctance to tackle, turning the Irish 10 channel into a glaring weakness.
Ratings
- Rugby Pass: 4.5
- Planet Rugby: 3
- FloRugby 4
- BALLS: 4
Comments
BALLS: “Like the rest of the team, struggled once France took over. Like his rivals for the 10 shirt, could be accused of overplaying at times, but did improve in the second half.”
FloRugby: "Defensively, he was heavily involved in the opening two French tries and missed seven tackles. While he did make 20 tackles overall, the damage had already been done."
Rugby Pass: “Had his moments in attack but steers Ireland like a drunken F1 driver – plenty of skill but liable to appalling lapses in judgement. Improved as Ireland enjoyed a short-lived second-half purple patch.”
Planet Rugby: “It gets to the point where you question if a 10 can continually get picked when they can’t tackle or, as it seems at times, simply won’t tackle. Prendergast started off well enough with a lovely cross-field kick but his defensive issues then cost Ireland. He refuses to put his body on the line which is unacceptable at any level but particularly in the Test arena. An utterly woeful display.”
3 Jacob Stockdale
Given a chance to reassert himself at Test level, Stockdale endured a frustrating return to the Six Nations spotlight. A missed tackle for France’s opener set the tone, and despite some aerial competitiveness, his defensive shortcomings again came to the fore.
Ratings
Rugby Pass: 4
Planet Rugby: 4
BALLS: 4
Planet Rugby: 4
BALLS: 4
Comments
BALLS: “A frustrating night having missed the tackle on Bielle-Biarrey for France's first try. Competed well aerially against Theo Attissogbe, but Ireland struggled on the transition phases all night.”
Planet Rugby: “Given an opportunity ahead of the out-of-form James Lowe but it was a day to forget on the left wing. Stockdale’s defence has been criticised in the past and his tackle attempt on Louis Bielle-Biarrey for the first try was abysmal. It didn’t get much better after that.”
Rugby Pass: “His first Six Nations game in four years, Stockdale failed to take a high ball with his first touch. Tried to be useful, but it’s not immediately clear what exactly Stockdale brings to the table at this level anymore.”
4 Joe McCarthy
McCarthy showed glimpses of his raw physicality but ultimately looked overwhelmed by France’s power and precision. Penalties, handling errors and a lack of impact in contact summed up a difficult evening that ended with an early second-half withdrawal.
Ratings
- Rugby Pass: 4.5
- Planet Rugby: 4
- BALLS: 4
- RUCK: 5
- FloRugby 4
Comments
FloRugby: "Replaced in the 49th minute, his evening ended without the influence Ireland desperately needed. It was a frustrating night for a player built for contests like this."
RUCK: “Returned with some set-piece success, but conceded a needless penalty at a dangerous area by flying into the side of a ruck, allowing Ramos to slot an easy three. A midfield pass later slipped through his legs, summing up a difficult first half.”
BALLS: “The only real physical presence in the Irish pack, and it showed. France double teamed McCarthy when he carried and although he defended well, it wasn't his night.”
Rugby Pass: “A deflated figure. Struggled to put a dent in the French pack in the opening forty, where it was largely one-way traffic. An awkward fumble or two, and had the general air of someone who didn’t look up to the task at hand.”
Planet Rugby: “Helped to stop the France maul from gaining too much traction, but there were a couple of needless penalties, including one absolute brain fade. Was taken off early in the second period.”
5 Garry Ringrose
Ringrose was largely anonymous as Ireland’s backline unravelled under pressure. Starved of attacking opportunities and unable to slow France’s momentum in defence, his usually reliable intensity and edge never truly surfaced on a sobering night in Paris.
Ratings
- BALLS: 4
- Planet Rugby: 5
- FloRugby 4
- Rugby Pass: 5
Comments
FloRugby: "Defensively, six tackles were offset by four misses, a costly return at this level. A disappointing night for a player of his calibre."
Rugby Pass: “Largely an onlooker in the first half, with Ireland’s backline at times resembling a panic-stricken engine room in a submarine that’s about to be torpedoed. Chased shadows all evening and looked off the pace.”
Planet Rugby: “Barely noticeable quite frankly, irrespective of his break late on. Didn’t have too many opportunities with ball in hand and could not halt the French juggernaut in defence.”
BALLS: “With a backline lacking cohesion, Ireland needed a trademark Ringrose performance. Unfortunately however his aggressive defensive style caused more damage than good, given how lethal Les Bleus were.”
If you want this styled even more “listicle-native” (shorter spacing, quote pull-outs, or reordered by rating severity), I can dial that in too.
TRENDING
LATEST NEWS
LATEST COMMENTS
- Jordie Barrett over Damian de Allende is far from being correct. The hype around Dupont is also overreaching, he's probably 4th in the world and has been since the 2023 WC. He also avoids certain matchups which is strange. The rest of the list is pretty good apart from minor subjective biases.JasonMarlow16-09-2026
Loading
