Sir Ian McGeechan ranked the SEVEN best rugby players of all-time

Rugby News
Tuesday, 28 April 2026 at 18:49
screenshot 2026 04 28 at 181209
Sir Ian McGeechan is one of rugby’s most respected figures — a Lions coach, former international, and one of the sharpest tactical minds the game has produced.
Four tours as head coach, two as a player, and decades shaping elite Test rugby have given him a rare perspective on greatness.
In his widely discussed selection for
The Telegraph, McGeechan highlighted seven players he regards as among the finest he has ever seen — spanning eras, hemispheres, and playing styles.
Join the RUCK’s WhatsApp community here and get the latest news sent straight to your messages.

#7 Brian O’Driscoll (Ireland)

A defining centre of the professional era, O’Driscoll combined vision, footwork, and defensive intelligence at the highest level.
McGeechan consistently placed him among the elite midfielders of his generation, recognising his ability to decide Test matches almost single-handedly.

“A world-class centre capable of defining Test matches.” (McGeechan series commentary)

#6 Richie McCaw (New Zealand)

The benchmark for modern openside play, McCaw’s influence extended far beyond the breakdown.
His leadership and game intelligence made him the central figure of a dominant All Blacks era.

“Quite possibly the greatest rugby player of all time.” (McGeechan)
“His understanding of the game made him such a brilliant player.” (McGeechan)

#5 Jonah Lomu (New Zealand)

A phenomenon who changed rugby’s perception of pace, power, and wing play.
Lomu’s impact at the 1995 Rugby World Cup remains one of the sport’s defining moments.

“The game needed a superstar, and it got one in Lomu. He was brilliant for rugby.” (McGeechan)
“His performances… will never be forgotten.” (McGeechan)

#4 Martin Johnson (England)

The defining forward leader of his generation and captain of England’s 2003 Rugby World Cup-winning side.
Johnson embodied control, physicality, and authority in the tight five.

“I think he defined an era, both for forward play and for the performances of the teams he represented.” (McGeechan)

#3 Dan Carter (New Zealand)

The complete modern fly-half — precise, composed, and tactically exceptional.
Carter set new standards for game management and kicking accuracy.

“He really was the complete 10.” (McGeechan)
“The greatest of the modern era in my opinion.” (McGeechan)

#2 Zinzan Brooke (New Zealand)

A forward ahead of his time, combining power, handling, and unexpected creativity.
Brooke’s ability to link play and contribute across phases made him a unique figure in Test rugby.

“His ability to bring others into the game… exemplary.” (McGeechan)
“A true original.” (McGeechan)

#1 Gareth Edwards (Wales)

For McGeechan, the greatest of them all.
A defining figure of Welsh rugby’s golden era, Edwards redefined the scrum-half role with vision and instinct.

“Gareth Edwards was and always will be the master.” (McGeechan)
“My favourite player of all time.” (McGeechan)
“The greatest.” (McGeechan)

LATEST RUGBY NEWS

loading

Loading