Sonny Bill Williams played alongside two of rugby's greatest-ever fly-halves. But when the two-time World Cup winner picked his dream team, Jonny Wilkinson made the cut while Dan Carter missed out.
The former All Blacks superstar enjoyed an extraordinary career, winning Rugby World Cups in 2011 and 2015 and playing alongside some of the biggest names in the sport.
He shared a dressing room with Wilkinson at Toulon before returning to New Zealand, where he played alongside Carter for the All Blacks.
Few players have experienced the talents of both legendary No.10s at such close quarters.
But when Williams was asked by Sporting News in 2015 to select 14 players who had made the biggest impression on him across rugby union and league, his choices raised eyebrows.
Wilkinson was included. Carter wasn't.
Sonny Bill Williams explains Jonny Wilkinson selection
Williams reserved special praise for the England legend, having witnessed his remarkable professionalism during their time together in France.
As previously reported by RUCK, Williams said: "I'm lucky enough to say I've played with Jonny Wilkinson and have seen the commitment that he had."
He added: "When I played with him, he was pretty much at the height of his powers, but the way he dedicated himself to his craft was unbelievable and I learnt a lot from him."
His selections also featured Jonah Lomu, France legend Thierry Dusautoir and fellow New Zealand fly-half Aaron Cruden.
Carter was not the only surprising omission. Former All Blacks captain Richie McCaw also missed out.
However, Williams was choosing players who had made the greatest impression on him rather than producing a definitive ranking of rugby's best.
That distinction matters, although Wilkinson's inclusion remains a remarkable endorsement.
Even Dan Carter picked Jonny Wilkinson
The story takes another fascinating turn when you consider Carter's own verdict.
During a Midi Olympique challenge, the legendary All Blacks fly-half was asked to choose between some of the greatest No.10s in rugby history.
And despite his own extraordinary achievements, Carter eventually selected Wilkinson.
"I would have to go Jonny. He was just someone I aspired to be like and someone I really respected, so Jonny Wilkinson," Carter explained.

Copyright: imago/Sportimage
Jonny Wilkinson (England)
"He was an awesome player."
Who really is rugby's greatest No.10?
The numbers make the argument almost impossible to settle.
Carter finished his international career with a record 1,598 Test points, two Rugby World Cup titles and three World Rugby Player of the Year awards.
Wilkinson famously kicked England to glory at the 2003 Rugby World Cup and retired with 1,246 international points.
Both changed the game, although their styles were very different.
Carter brought extraordinary attacking vision and control, while Wilkinson became renowned for his relentless preparation, defensive commitment and ice-cold kicking.
The pair also finished first and second in RUCK's ranking of rugby's greatest fly-halves, with Wilkinson taking top spot.
Williams' dream team was never intended to settle the argument.
But with the former All Blacks superstar selecting Wilkinson and Carter himself choosing the England legend, it is clear just how highly rugby's greatest players regard him.
The GOAT debate will continue. But Wilkinson has two rather impressive endorsements in his corner.
🏉 Think you know your rugby? Prove it.
Dan Carter or Jonny Wilkinson? Now it's your turn to make the big calls.
Build your Ultimate Rugby XV by drafting the world's best players, past and present. Balance your squad, chase the highest score and see if you can top the leaderboard.











