Rugby fans are fiercely debating the similarities between two serious injuries suffered by players facing Ireland in recent times.
Find your local Greene King pub and settle in for the 2025 Six Nations!
Both Malcolm Marx and Antoine Dupont sustained significant injuries, and with comparisons circulating online, many South African supporters have taken to social media to criticize Ireland’s actions, drawing parallels between the two incidents.
Irish Tactics or Just Rugby Accidents?
The claims have sparked a heated discussion, with just as many voices defending Tadhg Beirne and dismissing the controversy as an unfortunate rugby accident.
One fan wrote: “Antoine Dupont getting the Irish treatment. That snide hit on him reminded me of Marx last year vs Ireland. Dirty. Dirty buggers.”
Another added:
Case Closed? Not So Fast!
While France referred the actions of both Beirne and Andrew Porter for review, the Citing Commissioner ruled out further action, effectively clearing them of any intentional wrongdoing.
France Sees Red Over No Review
However, an outraged Florian Grill insists that France will explore ways to challenge the decision, expressing frustration that referee Angus Gardner did not conduct an official review during the match.
“Anger must not take over, and we will respect the final decisions,” the FFR president told L’Équipe. *”But we are determined to activate all possible appeals to make our voices heard.
“What shocked us, or bothered us, is that the referee did not go and study the images of Antoine’s injury himself. We find that disturbing. Eventually, we will be heard.”*
Win a rugby jersey every week with our Six Nations predictor
EDITORS PICKS:
- Join Greene King for the Six Nations
- Antoine Dupont injury update: France make devastating statement
- Win a trip to the 2025 Lions tour
- Peter O’Mahony Avoids Punishment After Final Act of Sh**housery for Ireland
- Statement: THREE Ireland players cited following France defeat
- Five players Ireland must drop after France defeat – who should replace them
Eight Players Who Flopped in Round Four of the Six Nations
The fourth round of the 2025 Six Nations saw England overpower Italy 47-24 at Twickenham, France reign supreme in a 42-27 victory over Ireland in Dublin, and Scotland edge past Wales 35-29 in a thriller at Murrayfield.
Despite the thrilling action, several players underperformed. Here’s a summary of the eight who struggled, with quotes from the key publications.
#1. Ellis Genge (England)
Planet Rugby: “Again, didn’t get to do much scrummaging but on the whole was fine. Carried hard when given the chance and got about in defence.”
Telegraph: “Probably his quietest performance of the Championship so far. Won an early scrum penalty but then got pinged for sealing off right in front of the posts.”
Mail Online: Warned for protesting with referee in the first half after being penalised for sealing off. Added a couple of trademark carries in attack.
Evening Standard: “Warned by the referee for his reaction to giving away a contentious late first-half penalty as he had too much to say for himself. Not his best day otherwise but useful in the loose.”
#2. Peter O’Mahony (Ireland)
UCK 4/10: “One last home run-out for the veteran. Will be disappointed with his work rate as his side fell apart shortly after he departed for Conan.”
Rugby Pass 5/10: “The mind is willing but the body was struggling to keep up. Fell off Antoine Dupont for France’s first try and looked a yard or two off the pace throughout, although there was no lack of industry, grit or heart from the Munster veteran.”
Planet Rugby 5/10: “ucky to get away with a few infringements with some rather kind officiating. But the rub of the green went the other way for a crucial call with many claiming that he attempted to milk a penalty. Again a real weapon at the lineout. It’s not the result the Ireland legend deserved in his final home outing but it wasn’t his best showing either.”
Balls 5/10: “Did well in the lineout but game roared past him on a few occasions. Was taken out before the Boudehent try but Angus Gardner opted to ignore.”
