Skip to content

Ireland Player Ratings vs South Africa: Two 9/10s in massive Ireland victory

Ireland Rugby News
imago1086174984h
Ireland picked up a massive win over South Africa, as Andy Farrell's men were forced to fight tooth and nail for a victory over the World Champions.
The visitors trailed for most of the game, however the South African threat loomed for most of the game. Three tries for the home side, Ireland looked for most of the game to pick up the bonus point try and solidify their place in third.
Jamison Gibson Park and Joe McCarthy were among the best performers for Ireland on the night, as one player didn't quite cover himself in glory with a 3/10 rating.
Here are our Ireland player ratings vs South Africa.
Scroll down for Ireland Player Ratings vs the Springboks

Ireland Player Ratings vs South Africa: Every Star Rated 

15. Hugo Keenan – 7/10

Targeted early on by an aggressive South African high ball and coped well. Part of an Ireland back three that saw Ireland dominate field position. The most consistent 15 in World Rugby at the moment. Aerial contest was one of the most important parts of Ireland's win over South Africa, with Keenan playing a massive part alongside Hansen and Baloucoune.

14. Robert Baloucoune – 8/10

Capped off a try with his own brand of flair, forcing a difficult finish in the corner to give Ireland their first lead of the game. One of the most in-form and dynamic wingers in World Rugby at the moment and a threat every time he gets the ball in hand. An emphatic finish for Ireland's second. Deserved player of the match, finishing the night with the most carries as well as an emphatic performance with the ball in hand, with the most defenders beaten.

13. Robbie Henshaw – 5/10 

12. Stuart McCloskey – 7/10

Set an early explosive start. Got in the face of the South African line and carried well. Beautiful pass to his Ulster teammate to send Ireland over for the opening score. Finished the night with 11 carries. Also tackled superbly, finishing the night with 11 tackles.

11. Mack Hansen – 6/10

Where Ireland's scrum faltered, it was the back three that picked up the pace. All three gave Andy Farrell's side possession with their aggression under the high ball and set play, particularly Hansen, who tracked the ball aggressively and didn't give South Africa any time to breathe. Great play to rescue the ball and set up Baloucoune for his second try.

10. Sam Prendergast – 5/10

After all the drama in the week over Sam Prendergast's inclusion, the Ireland ten didn't exactly light the Aviva on fire. Struggled from the tee, and creative duties were taken over by Gibson Park. Made some errors with the ball in hand at times during the first half. Kicked poorly and put most of his first receivers in danger of getting caught behind the gain line.

9. Jamison Gibson Park – 9/10

Performance might go under the radar but one of the biggest pieces to Ireland's success in the first half. The box-kicking game was Ireland's biggest point of attack, and the Irish 9 completely controlled it. A massive tackle stopped South Africa from picking up their second try of the game.

1. Andrew Porter – 7/10 

After such a strong day at set pieces against Fiji, Ireland tried to lay down an early marker against the Springboks scrum and failed. His knock-on in South Africa's 22 was potentially the biggest momentum swing of the game, despite Ireland holding on. Despite the issues at scrum time, Ireland's scrum did cope in the biggest moments, and Porter himself also finished the night with a massive impact, with 10 carries.

2. Ronan Kelleher – 7/10 

Massive performance on the night and stepped up perfectly. Picked up a try, and made his impact felt across the entire park, while also performing near perfectly come lineout time.

3. Tadhg Furlong – 7/10

Came up with some massive moments, with an early turnover in the game as well as picking up a scrum penalty against a dominant Springbok scrum. The set piece was still completely dismantled across the first half despite his individual performance. Got stuck in without the ball in the ruck, making his presence felt on Saturday.

4. Joe McCarthy – 9/10

Ireland's turnover game early in the first half gave Ireland a perfect platform for attack. Set Ireland up in South Africa's 22 with its first turnover of the game. Also, Ireland's biggest player without the ball in hand, with the most tackles on the night against a typically dominant South African back row. Ireland's best performer on the night.

5. Tadhg Beirne – 6/10

Ireland's turnover game thrived on Saturday night, and Tadhg Beirne can always be looked to when that happens. Finished the night without a turnover but still made his presence felt in the ruck. Also carried well with ball in hand.

6. Ryan Baird – 8/10

The Ireland 6 has become a mainstay and one of the most important parts of Ireland's set-piece game since his return, both in their own lineout and in competition with South Africa. Across the night, Ireland had a near 100% lineout win percentage. Made a nuisance of himself all over the park, finishing the night with the most tackles from an Ireland perspective, with 15 tackles. Nailed on in the Ireland team following his return from injury.

7. Josh Van Der Flier – 7/10 

Looked back to his usual individual best after weeks of his place in the squad being questioned. One of the most dominant players with the ball in hand on the night, finishing the first half with 7 carries and the game with 10.

8. Dan Sheehan – 7/10

Carried well and looked every part of an international-standard 8, with the most carries for Ireland across the opening 40. Made natural mistakes at times that came from his unfamiliarity with the position, being caught isolated on multiple occasions, but did enough of a job that Ireland hardly noticed their lack of a proper 8. Also flashed his usual brilliant handling at times, with a massive rescue early in the second. Lost a ranking for his yellow card at the most vital point of the game.

Replacements – 7/10

Replacements didn't make a massive impact, with the South African bomb squad nullifying Ireland's bench. However, Ulster hooker Tom Stewart offered a dynamic spark to give Ireland some momentum as they looked to hang onto a lead with just a quarter of the game left to go. The replacement pack also struggled to cope with the South African front row, as expected, but came up big when it mattered most.

⭐ Rate the Ireland players yourself!

Think we've been too harsh? Or too generous?
Now it's your turn to judge. Rate every Ireland player out of five stars following their clash with South Africa and see how your scores compare with fellow fans.
👇 Have your say below!
loading

LATEST COMMENTS

Loading