Springboks player ratings vs Ireland 2026: South Africa fell to a frustrating 20-17 defeat in Dublin as Rassie Erasmus's side failed to make their forward dominance count.
The Springboks caused Ireland all sorts of problems at scrum time, but their attack was a different story. They had chances to win it late on and couldn't take them.
Malcolm Marx and Morne van den Berg scored South Africa's tries, while Sacha Feinberg-Mngomezulu kicked seven points and produced a superb try-saving tackle.
There were some decent performances up front, but several big names failed to deliver.
The defeat followed last week's loss to France, while Erasmus had already made headlines over his controversial Springboks watchalong.
Here are our Springboks player ratings against Ireland, with every starter graded out of 10.
Springboks player ratings vs Ireland
15. Damian Willemse – 4/10
Not his afternoon. His attempted intervention helped create Baloucoune's second try, and he struggled to make much happen going forward. South Africa needed a spark from their full-back, but it never came.
14. Kurt-Lee Arendse – 5/10
Looked dangerous when he found space, beating two defenders before creating an opening for Moodie. However, a costly penalty and some frustrating moments meant he never really got going. Expected more.
13. Jesse Kriel – 5/10
A quiet one for Kriel. Ireland's midfield gave South Africa plenty to think about, and he rarely threatened with ball in hand. His late knock-on ended the Springboks' final chance to rescue the match. A frustrating finish for one of their most experienced players.
12. Damian de Allende – 6/10
One of South Africa's better defenders, producing two dominant tackles and bringing his usual physical edge to midfield. Didn't get many opportunities in attack, but put himself about.
11. Ethan Hooker – 3/10
Won't enjoy watching Ireland's opening try again. Rob Baloucoune brushed aside his attempted tackle far too easily before racing into the corner. A costly mistake that set the tone for a difficult afternoon. A harsh lesson for the youngster.
10. Sacha Feinberg-Mngomezulu – 5/10
Produced one outstanding moment when he somehow held Dan Sheehan up over the line. Unfortunately, there wasn't much else to shout about. Struggled to get South Africa moving in attack and made some poor decisions. That try-saving intervention rescued his rating.
9. Morne van den Berg – 5/10
Right place, right time for his try as the Springboks scrum shoved Ireland backwards. Less impressive late on when he ran straight into his own teammate with South Africa camped near the Irish line. A costly error when his side desperately needed points.
1. Ox Nche – 7/10
Ireland won't be sorry to see the back of him. Caused plenty of problems at scrum time and helped give South Africa their best attacking platform. Did his job, although the Springboks couldn't make enough of their dominance.
2. Malcolm Marx – 7/10
One of South Africa's better performers. Carried hard, scored a vital second-half try and kept throwing himself into the contest. His efforts gave the Springboks a chance, but they couldn't finish the job.
3. Wilco Louw – 7/10
Had the upper hand at scrum time. Ireland struggled to contain the Springboks' shove, particularly for Van den Berg's try. Did exactly what was asked of him. Unfortunately, the backs couldn't make the most of the platform.
4. Eben Etzebeth – 7/10
Three dominant tackles and a late charge-down summed up his afternoon. Brought plenty of aggression and never stopped working, even as South Africa struggled to find a way through.
5. Franco Mostert – 6/10
Got through plenty of defensive work and was one of South Africa's busiest tacklers. Conceded an early penalty, though, and couldn't help his side turn their forward pressure into points. A decent shift without being spectacular.
6. Siya Kolisi – 6/10
Backed his forwards to get the job done, repeatedly choosing scrums when penalties were on offer. You could understand the thinking given how well South Africa were scrummaging. Unfortunately, the points didn't follow.
7. Pieter-Steph du Toit – 6/10
Produced a brilliant second-half break and offload that almost sent Moodie over. Made the odd mistake, including an early knock-on, but never stopped looking for work. Not quite at his destructive best.
8. Cameron Hanekom – 7/10
Won two turnovers and got through plenty of work against a tough Irish back row. Didn't do much wrong and was one of the few Springboks who could be reasonably satisfied with his contribution.
Springboks replacements – 4/10
Thomas du Toit made his presence felt with a powerful carry that flattened Jamison Gibson-Park, while Marco van Staden produced a superb surge in the build-up to Marx's try. Canan Moodie was a mixed bag, making two line breaks and coming close to scoring before Mack Hansen forced him into touch. However, he also lost possession three times, while Gerhard Steenekamp conceded a needless late penalty. The bench brought plenty of muscle, but not enough composure when it mattered.
Rate the Springboks players yourself! Have your say on every Bok's performance against Ireland. Give each player a rating out of five stars and see how your verdict compares with fellow fans.















