In an era defined by sensationalism and exaggerated media coverage in the world of sports, it's undeniable that some athletes find themselves in the spotlight, garnering more attention and acclaim than their actual performance merits.
In the realm of sports, our loyalty to particular teams often leads us to champion their players with a fervor usually reserved for our closest kin.
However, in the interest of objectivity, we've set aside these allegiances to compile a list of the Rugby World Cup's top five players who, according to fans, may have received more accolades than their on-field contributions warrant.
- ITV will be broadcasting every Rugby World Cup fixture live.
- For the travelling rugby fan, check out our supporter’s guide to Lille.
- Win a signed England jersey with Charles Tyrwhitt
- Find your local Greene King pub to watch the rugby
- Secure your seat for the Six Nations with viagogo
#1. Marcus Smith (England)
One fan wrote: "Tries to dazzle in attack to compensate for his fear of the tackle. That's fine if England were dominating the forward battle ensuring limitless ball for the backs. Sadly there aren't so the rest of the backs are in effect defending with one short."
Another said: "he has potential to be immense, but is still lacking in a lot of areas and as shown this 6n, isn't as good at game managment as England's other options. Also the media don't help trying to turn him into the next Cipriani."
A third commented: "e's got the potential to be very good. But if you listened to the ITV/BBC commentators talking about him you'd think they were describing 2005 Carter and he's just nowhere near that"
#2. Liam Williams (Wales)
One fan wrote: "I would say Liam Williams is massively overrated. The guy hasn’t looked top class for the better part of a year - the odd 50:22 and fancy pass doesn’t get him off for being braindead on attack and dirty on defence."
#3. Maro Itoje (England)
One fan wrote: "Overrated..compared to his peak you could say Itoje.. but then even his worst days.. he's still pretty damm good.."
#4. Finn Russell (Scotland)
One fan wrote: "Finn Russell and Finn Russell."
#5. Josh van der Flier (Ireland)
One fan wrote: "His consistency is impressive but he isn't going to change a game. He doesn't come up with many turnovers, not great at the breakdown or in the lineout and his carrying has improved but he's not exactly a Sean O'Brien in that department either. There weren't too many complaints when he missed out on lions selection last year."
Josh van der Flier of Ireland during the Summer International match between England and Ireland at Twickenham Stadium, Twickenham, London on the 24th August 2019. Photo: Phil Mingo/PPAUK.
