Duhan van der Merwe’s eligibility for Scotland questioned ahead of England clash
Rugby NewsTuesday, 18 February 2025 at 22:01
Duhan van der Merwe cemented his place in rugby folklore with a sensational hat-trick against England in the Calcutta Cup showdown 12 months ago.
Find your local Greene King and settle in for the 2025 Six Nations!
Now, Gregor Townsend’s men are chasing an unprecedented fifth consecutive Calcutta Cup victory as they prepare to face their old rivals once again.
Twickenham fortress? Not for Scotland
Scotland haven’t tasted defeat at Twickenham since 2017 – the year England clinched the Six Nations title and matched New Zealand’s record of 18 consecutive men’s Test wins with a brutal 61-21 triumph.
Since then, it’s been all Scotland. With two wins and a draw in their last three visits, the Scots have turned the tables on their Southern rivals – and England’s four-match losing streak in this fixture tells its own story.
Steve Borthwick’s side, however, are desperate to keep their title ambitions alive with clashes against Italy and Wales still to come. Meanwhile, Scotland – fresh off a win over Italy – are looking to bounce back after a bruising defeat to tournament favourites Ireland.
Van der Merwe’s special connection with England
For van der Merwe, scoring against England carries extra weight. Reflecting on his hat-trick heroics, he admitted:
“It’s obviously very special scoring a hat-trick for Scotland, even more so against England.”
And it seems the fans can’t get enough – on and off the pitch.
Social media erupts over Duhan’s "Scottishness"
While van der Merwe’s performances speak for themselves, his eligibility remains a lightning rod for debate. The winger qualified for Scotland through the now-defunct three-year residency rule – and some fans are still struggling to accept it.
One fan quipped:
“I’m sorry but it’s hilarious how un-Scottish Duhan van der Merwe is.”
Another joked:
“One thinks Scotland might be trying to pull a fast one with this great Scottish player Duhan van der Merwe.”
A third added:
“The hilarious thing about Duhan van der Merwe is how ridiculously un-Scottish he is. The name. The accent. And physically, there isn’t a Scottish man that looks like him.”
Love him or loathe him, one thing’s for sure – when it comes to the Calcutta Cup, Duhan van der Merwe is the man England fans love to hate.
EDITORS PICKS:
- Sergio Parisse didn’t blink when asked who his toughest opponent was…
- British & Irish Lions to play France in first match of its kind
- England team to play Scotland: 2025 Six Nations
- Statement: Major Harlequins star has signed for Sale Sharks
- Sir Clive Woodward reveals his Lions XV – no place for Fin or Marcus Smith
UPDATED: Foreign-born players in the 2025 Six Nations
The following breakdown, based on data compiled by Americas Rugby News, examines the composition of various national teams, shedding light on the number of foreign-born players and how they qualify for their respective squads.
This international blend underlines rugby’s global nature, with some nations leaning on overseas-born talent more than others. Ahead of round two, we've broken down the squads – and Scotland lead the way by a mile when it comes to foreign-born players.
ENGLAND
HOMEGROWN PLAYERS: 39/41 (95.2%)
FOREIGN-BORN PLAYERS: 3/41 (7.3%)
FOREIGN-BORN PLAYERS: 3/41 (7.3%)
- Bevan Rodd (Scotland) - Parent
- Chandler Cunningham-South (England) - Born in England
- Harry Randall (England) - Born in England
- Marcus Smith (Philippines) - Parent
- Tom Roebuck (Scotland) - Parent
FRANCE
HOMEGROWN PLAYERS: 39/42 (92.8%)
FOREIGN-BORN PLAYERS: 6/42 (14.2%)
FOREIGN-BORN PLAYERS: 6/42 (14.2%)
- Dany Priso (Cameroon) - Residency (2008)
- Uini Atonio (New Zealand) - Residency (2014)
- Giorgi Beria (Georgia) - Residency (2002)
- Joshua Brennan (Ireland) - Residency (2005)
- Emmanuel Meafou (New Zealand) - Residency (2023)
- Émilien Gailleton (England) - Parent
IRELAND
HOMEGROWN PLAYERS: 30/36 (83.3%)
FOREIGN-BORN PLAYERS: 9/36 (25%)
FOREIGN-BORN PLAYERS: 9/36 (25%)
- Rob Herring (South Africa) - Grandparent
- Finlay Bealham (Australia) - Grandparent
- Cormac Izuchukwu (England) - Parent
- Joe McCarthy (USA) - Parent
- Jamison Ratu Gibson-Park (New Zealand) - Residency (2020)
- Bundee Aki (New Zealand) - Residency (2017)
- Ciarán Frawley (Australia) - Parent
- Mack Hansen (Australia) - Parent
- James Lowe (New Zealand) - Residency (2020)
ITALY
HOMEGROWN PLAYERS: 21/31 (67.7%)
FOREIGN-BORN PLAYERS: 9/31 (29.0%)
FOREIGN-BORN PLAYERS: 9/31 (29.0%)
- Dino Lamb-Cona (England) - Parent
- Sebastian Negri (Zimbabwe) - Parent
- Ross Vintcent (South Africa) - Grandparent
- Martin Page-Relo (France) - Grandparent
- Stephen Varney (Wales) - Parent
- Juan Ignacio Brex (Argentina) - Grandparent
- Montana Ioane (Australia) - Residency (2020)
- Ange Capuozzo (France) - Parent
- Matt Gallagher (England) - Parent
SCOTLAND
HOMEGROWN PLAYERS: 25/42 (58,1.3%)
FOREIGN-BORN PLAYERS: 18/43 (44.1%)
FOREIGN-BORN PLAYERS: 18/43 (44.1%)
- Pierre Schoeman (South Africa) - Residency (2021)
- Ewan Ashman (Canada) - Parent
- Dylan Richardson (South Africa) - Parent
- Will Hurd (England) - Grandparent
- Cameron Henderson (Hong Kong) - Parent
- Ewan Johnson (England) - Parent
- Marshall Sykes (England) - Grandparent
- Josh Bayliss (England) - Grandparent
- Jack Dempsey (Australia) - Grandparent
- Alexander Masibaka (Australia) - Parent
- Ben White (England) - Grandparent
- Fergus Burke (New Zealand) - Grandparent
- Tom Jordan (New Zealand) - Residency (2024)
- Rory Hutchinson (England) - Grandparent
- Sione Tuipulotu (Australia) - Grandparent
- Arron Reed (England) - Parent
- Kyle Rowe (England) - Cumulative Residency
- Duhan van der Merwe (South Africa) - Residency (2020)
WALES
HOMEGROWN PLAYERS: 26/34 (76.4%)
FOREIGN-BORN PLAYERS: 10/34 (29.4%)
FOREIGN-BORN PLAYERS: 10/34 (29.4%)
- WillGriff John (England) - Parent
- Henry Thomas (England) - Parent
- Will Rowlands (England) - Parent
- Freddie Thomas (England) - Grandparent
- Christ Tshiunza (DR Congo) - Residency (2015)
- James Botham (Wales) - Born in Wales
- Taulupe Faletau (Tonga) - Residency (2001)
- Ellis Bevan (England) - Parent
- Nick Tompkins (England) - Grandparent
- Blair Murray (New Zealand) - Parent
- Ellis Mee (England) - Parent
Predictor Game:
If you are not sure, simply hit 'Shuffle' and you will be given an automated prediction.
Once you are happy with the selection, hit 'Submit Prediction' to enter.
You will receive points if either/both of your predictions occur during the live match.
POINTS
5 Points: Total Tries Correct
15 Points: Time of 1st Try Correct
15 Points: Time of 1st Try Correct
A winner will be selected from those with the most points at the end of the game week
TRENDING
LATEST NEWS
LATEST COMMENTS
- Jordie Barrett over Damian de Allende is far from being correct. The hype around Dupont is also overreaching, he's probably 4th in the world and has been since the 2023 WC. He also avoids certain matchups which is strange. The rest of the list is pretty good apart from minor subjective biases.JasonMarlow16-09-2026
Loading