Skip to content

Eight Players Who Flopped in the Six Nations This Weekend

Rugby News
screenshot 2025 02 09 at 203544
The second round of the 2025 Six Nations saw Italy defeat Wales 22-15 in Rome, England edge France 26-25 at Twickenham, and Ireland secure a dominant 32-18 victory over Scotland at Murrayfield.
Despite the thrilling action, several players underperformed. Here’s a summary of the eight who struggled, with quotes from the key publications.

1. Finn Russell (Scotland)

  • Rugby Pass 4.5/10: "Lost a couple of high hanging kicks... Forced off after 21 minutes following a head collision."
  • RUCK 5/10: "Couldn't get his nation ticking in the early stages."
  • The Scotsman: "Limited impact on the game early on as Ireland took control."
Verdict: Russell was underwhelming, leaving Scotland on the back foot from the start.

2. Jonny Gray (Scotland)

  • Rugby Pass 5/10: "Struggled to make an impact and was replaced early in the second half."
  • Planet Rugby 5/10: "A few good moments in the set-piece, but nothing substantial."
Verdict: Gray was largely ineffective and couldn’t contribute to Scotland’s fightback.

3. Antoine Dupont (France)

  • Rugby Pass 5/10: "Had a few sloppy passes and missed a try-scoring chance."
  • Mail Online 6/10: "Far from his best but still involved in setting up tries."
Verdict: Dupont’s usual brilliance was lacking, and he struggled with errors that disrupted France’s rhythm.

4. Josh Adams (Wales)

  • RUCK 3/10: "Butchered two try-scoring opportunities and got a yellow card."
  • Planet Rugby 4/10: "Missed two huge chances, lucky to escape a red card."
  • Wales Online 4/10: "Butchered two easy try-scoring chances and received a yellow card."
Verdict: Adams’ poor decision-making and missed opportunities overshadowed his performance.

5. Marcus Smith (England)

  • RUCK 5/10: "Struggled with decision-making and was inconsistent in attack and defence."
  • Evening Standard 5/10: "Lucky not to be punished for defensive lapses."
  • Planet Rugby 4/10: "His kicking woes made things difficult."
Verdict: Smith’s performance was mixed, with missed kicks and defensive mistakes.

6. Henry Thomas (Wales)

  • Planet Rugby 3/10: "Put under serious pressure in the scrum, conceded multiple penalties."
  • Wales Online 4/10: "Gave away four scrum penalties and was replaced at halftime."
  • RUCK 3/10: "Physically outmatched by the Italian pack."
Verdict: Thomas struggled at the scrum, and his performance hurt Wales’ forward dominance.

7. Evan Lloyd (Wales)

  • Planet Rugby 4/10: "Lineout misfired again and couldn’t help his props."
  • Wales Online 4/10: "Struggled in the lineout but solid in attack and defence."
  • RUCK 3/10: "Failed to make an impact at the lineout."
Verdict: Lloyd’s lack of impact in the lineout hurt Wales' set-piece.

8. Luke Cowan-Dickie (England)

  • Evening Standard 5/10: "Struggled with the lineout, losing three of six."
  • Rugby Pass 6/10: "Lineout issues disrupted England’s flow."
  • Express 6/10: "England’s lineout struggled in the first half."
Verdict: Cowan-Dickie’s struggles at the lineout disrupted England's set-piece.

EDITORS PICKS:

loading

LATEST COMMENTS

Loading