Sir Ian McGeechan's top five rugby players of all time – Wilkinson doesn’t make the list - Page 3 of 3 - Ruck

Sir Ian McGeechan’s top five rugby players of all time – Wilkinson doesn’t make the list

#2. Zinzan Brooke (New Zealand)

A dynamic force in New Zealand’s storied rugby legacy, Brooke’s versatility and flair elevated him to legendary status.

1

Renowned for his powerful runs, deft handling, and pinpoint accuracy, he became a symbol of the All Blacks’ relentless pursuit of excellence.

He wrote: “His ability to bring others into the game, his ability to stay connected in the game himself, popping up repeatedly through different phases; all exemplary.

“And he dropped goals of course. A true original.”

#1. Gareth Edwards (Wales)

A Welsh icon and arguably the greatest scrum-half in rugby history, Edwards redefined his position with his exceptional vision, speed, and game-changing abilities.

A key figure in Wales’ golden era of the 1970s, his name remains synonymous with rugby brilliance.

McGeechan wrote: “My favourite scrum-half of all time happens to be my favourite player of all time. Gareth Edwards was and always will be the master. The Greatest.”