- 10. Danny Cipriani (England) – “I think compared to normal players he’s pretty decent. But, we’re talking about being overrated, and Danny has been constantly touted by the media as the next big thing and he has definitely not lived up to that mantle.”
- 9. Ben Youngs (England) – “He is the most overrated English scrum half ever and isn’t in the top 4 scrum half’s in England let alone the world.”
- 1. Gethin Jenkins (Wales) – “Played for far too long. Was nowhere near international in the last few years yet still always got picked.”
- 2. Dylan Hartley (England) – ” Outside of the England dressing room, i guess he was never massively rated but, Jones specifically, loved him. I never saw him as international quality and more of a liability than anything else.”
- 3. Martin Castrogiovanni (Italy) – “Sure he had nice hair and liked dogs, but I’ve seen better skilled prop down my local rugby club.