"Inexcusable" - Four England players who flopped and who should replace them for second test

Rugby News
Saturday, 06 July 2024 at 10:48
screenshot 2024 07 06 at 104808
New Zealand narrowly defeated England 16-15 in a thrilling opening Test in Dunedin, marking a victorious start for new head coach Scott Robertson.
Join the RUCK’s WhatsApp community here and get the latest news sent straight to your messages.
Damian McKenzie secured the win with two crucial second-half penalties, overturning England's lead after Immanuel Feyi-Waboso's try had given the visitors a five-point advantage.
The teams were tied at half-time, with Sevu Reece and Ardie Savea scoring for New Zealand, while Maro Itoje's try, converted by Marcus Smith, kept England in contention.
Below, we look at what changes Steve Borthwick could make for next weekend's clash with the All Blacks at Eden Park.

#1. Marcus Smith

Rugby Pass 5/10: "Inexcusable miss in front of the posts early in the second half, but bounced back immediately with some passes timed to absolute perfection as England scored their second. After being penned back in the first half due to New Zealand’s territorial supremacy, he was able to express himself much more after the break as England gained more control. Unfortunately, two kicks from five are the statistics that can define Test matches though, and that might well have been the case in Dunedin"
Telegraph 6/10: "Missed two sitters off the tee which England had to take. Didn’t love the grubber when England were attacking well but two slick passes before Feyi-Waboso’s score. Bottom line, the missed points were critical. "
Planet Rugby 6/10: " Ultimately, those kicks were costly, while there was one errant decision in attack, but he still brought plenty to the game. Option-taking was good and he was absolutely central to Feyi-Waboso’s score. A mixed display but Smith deserves another shot."
Replacement: Fin Smith is waiting the wings, but we'd give Marcus another run out next weekend

#2. Joe Marler

Planet Rugby 4/10: "Only lasted 20 minutes, but we’re not sure he would have made too much of a difference to the scrum as it was already creaking."
Telegraph 5/10: "Early win at the scrum with a penalty but then absolutely smoked by Lomax. Forced off after 17 minutes to give his young club-mate Fin Baxter a debut."
Rugby Pass 5/10: "Scrum penalty won with five minutes on the clock in his battle with Tyrel Lomax, but found himself marching backwards a few minutes later. Left the field injured before 20 minutes had elapsed."
Replacement: Fin Baxter

#3. Tommy Freeman

Planet Rugby 5/10: " In contrast to Feyi-Waboso, Freeman had his issues without the ball. Some decent carries but there are improvements to be made."
Rugby Pass 5/10: "The All Blacks’ opening two tries were on his wing and though he was left severely isolated for the opening cross-field kick score, his positioning was poor for the second- although he would have expected Ben Earl to latch onto Stephen Perofeta. That can lead to players trying to force it a bit too much, which led to a knock-on. Was able to iron out many issues after the break though, and came off his wing nicely in the second 40."
Replacement: Freddie Steward would supply better safety under the high ball

#4. Ben Earl

Rugby Pass 5.5/10: "Missed a tackle anyone associated with England would have expected him to make on Perofeta in Ardie Savea’s try. One very costly error, but that’s all it takes at this level. England’s go-to man to crash into defenders in an epic battle with his counterpart Savea."
Telegraph 5/10: "Nice offload combining with Mitchell but given the slip by Perofeta and that missed tackle led to Savea’s score. Not his best though with a couple of soft mistakes."
Replacement: Go again
loading

Loading