Richie McCaw breaks silence on decision to reject knighthood honour

Rugby News
Sunday, 14 June 2026 at 17:57
richie mccaw humbled by nzs highest honour ive never been v0 iddmwl3fbjscm wkrcp9yorzvmo oswnihtaka phcjpg
While Sir Steve Hansen was awarded a knighthood in 2019 after overseeing one of the most dominant eras in rugby history, there’s one name fans still believe deserves the same honour: Richie McCaw.
The former All Blacks captain is widely regarded as the greatest player to ever pull on the famous black jersey, leading New Zealand to back-to-back Rugby World Cup titles and an unprecedented period of success.
Join the RUCK’s WhatsApp community here and get the latest news sent straight to your messages.
Yet despite his achievements, McCaw has never become "Sir Richie" – prompting the same question from rugby supporters year after year: why not?
McCaw, a two-time Rugby World Cup-winning captain, chose a different path. After leading the All Blacks to World Cup glory in 2015, he became the youngest-ever member of the prestigious Order of New Zealand, limited to just 20 living members. Many argue this honour surpasses a knighthood.

"It didn’t feel quite right"

Back in 2011, after McCaw captained the All Blacks to a triumphant World Cup win on home soil, then-Prime Minister John Key revealed he'd floated the idea of a knighthood. However, McCaw declined.
"In the end, the conclusion that he drew was that he would love to take it but now wasn’t the right time," Key told RadioSport. "He made the call that he’s still in his playing career and it didn’t feel quite right for him."
Key confirmed no formal offer was made. "We didn’t formally get to offer it to him in the sense that we knew if we offered it he wouldn’t take it."

"I don’t know whether that’s the right thing just yet"

After securing back-to-back World Cup wins in 2015, Richie McCaw was again in the spotlight for a knighthood. Yet, he remained reluctant. Speaking to TVNZ after the tournament, McCaw said:
"I’m still pretty young, so to have a title [knighthood] like that, I don’t know whether that’s the right thing just yet."
At the 2016 investiture ceremony where he officially joined the Order of New Zealand, McCaw reiterated his decision, saying it "sat more comfortably" with him.

"You can’t get any bigger than this"

Reflecting on his honours, Richie McCaw expressed no regrets about turning down a knighthood. "You can’t get any bigger than this," he said of the Order of New Zealand.
For McCaw, staying grounded remained a priority: "At the end of the day, you’re an ordinary Kiwi really. People expect you to behave like that … it’s one of the things I’ve always been strong on."

"A little embarrassing"

As the youngest-ever recipient of the Order of New Zealand, McCaw admitted the accolade felt slightly awkward. "I have had friends point that out to me," he laughed.
For now, the choice of whether he’ll ever become "Sir Richie" rests solely with McCaw himself. And knowing the man, he seems perfectly content as Richie McCaw—rugby’s greatest.

? Richie McCaw’s Dream Team – Based on the Players He Admired Most

Back Three – Speed, Skill, and Power

15. Christian Cullen (New Zealand)
The Paekakariki Express – pure attacking brilliance.
Cullen’s elusive running and flair from fullback made him one of the most exciting players of his generation. McCaw has often praised the “X-factor” players who changed games — and Cullen certainly fits that description.
14. Julian Savea (New Zealand)
Nicknamed “The Bus” for a reason.
Savea bulldozed defenders throughout the 2010s, becoming one of the All Blacks’ most prolific finishers. McCaw has spoken glowingly about the modern winger’s mix of strength and speed.
11. Jonah Lomu (New Zealand)
The sport’s first true global superstar.
Richie McCaw on Lomu:

“When I first became an All Black he was in the team. To play alongside a guy you had watched as a young fella was pretty amazing. He made me look silly in training more than once.
He’s one of the absolute superstars of rugby. If you go somewhere rugby isn’t well known, the one guy they do know is Jonah.”

Lomu’s passing at just 40 was deeply felt by McCaw, who described him as “a legend of the All Blacks and a legend of rugby.”

Centres – Creativity and Control

13. Ma’a Nonu (New Zealand)
A powerhouse with brains and finesse.
McCaw has long admired Nonu’s development from raw runner to one of the smartest midfielders in the game. His combination with Conrad Smith defined an era of All Blacks dominance.
12. Jonny Wilkinson (England)
The English icon and ultimate professional.
McCaw on Wilkinson:

“He’ll go down as one of the greats of world rugby.”
From his legendary 2003 World Cup-winning drop goal to his relentless preparation, Wilkinson earned universal respect — including from McCaw.

⚡ Halfbacks – Tactical Perfection

10. Dan Carter (New Zealand)
The ultimate playmaker.
Richie McCaw on Carter:

“There are a lot of good players, but the guys who did it for a long time — and that I’ve been lucky to play with — is Dan Carter. In the final, he was sensational and he’s been great for a long time.”
Few players embodied consistency and class like Carter.

9. Aaron Smith (New Zealand)
Sharp, smart, and relentless.
Smith’s crisp passing and control of tempo earned him McCaw’s admiration as one of the most influential All Black halfbacks ever.

Front Row – The Unsung Heroes

1. Tony Woodcock (New Zealand)
Dependable and destructive in equal measure.
McCaw on Woodcock:

“He’s been on the same team as me since I was 18. We played in age grade together.”
Woodcock’s try in the 2011 Rugby World Cup final sealed his place in All Black folklore.

2. Dane Coles (New Zealand)
A hooker with the heart of a back-rower.
McCaw has praised Coles’ aggression and athleticism, calling him one of the most dynamic forwards of the modern game.
3. Olo Brown (New Zealand)
Technically superb and built for the scrum wars of the ‘90s.
Brown’s reliability and scrummaging power made him one of New Zealand’s best-ever tightheads — the kind McCaw often admired for their unseen graft.

?️ Second Row – The Engine Room

4. Paul O’Connell (Ireland)
A colossus in green and one of McCaw’s toughest opponents.
O’Connell’s leadership, intelligence, and relentless intensity earned McCaw’s respect as one of rugby’s greatest captains.
5. Brodie Retallick (New Zealand)
A modern-day great.
McCaw has hailed Retallick’s athleticism and skill as a lock who “can do it all.” A true game-changer in tight and open play alike.

Back Row – Where Battles Are Won

6. Richard Hill (England)
The definition of consistency and class.
Richie McCaw on Hill:

“Extremely gifted player who had all the ability in the world to play and run the ball. When England needed someone to dig in, he was your man. He had the full tool bag and quietly got on with it.”

7. Schalk Burger (South Africa)
Fearless and ferocious.
McCaw on Burger:

“You can come up against another tough team but never feel like you’ve had a tough match against your opposite. But with Burger, you knew where he’d be and how hard he’d play near the ball.”
High praise from the toughest man in the game.

8. George Smith (Australia)
McCaw’s most respected rival.
McCaw on Smith:

“He was always pretty tough.”
In multiple interviews, McCaw admitted Smith was the one player he truly feared

 on the field — the ultimate compliment from the best flanker in history.

loading

Loading