England players ranked by average ratings vs Argentina: Guardian, Mail, Ruck...
Rugby NewsSunday, 12 November 2017 at 09:26
England's opening autumn international ended in the victory all of Twickenham expected, but the route to the result was a meandering amble rather than anything riotously uplifting.
However, as always each player ratings published had some big differences, with individuals scores in some cases ranging from 6/10 to 8.5/10.
We've taken the player ratings from a number of highly reputable publications (and ourselves) and averaged them out to get each player's definitive mark out of ten.
We've ordered them from worst to best:
15. Jonathan Joseph - 5.2/10
The Rugby Paper: 5
Guardian: 5
Mail: 5.5
RUCK: 5
14. Henry Slade - 5.5/10
The Rugby Paper: 4.5
Guardian: 6
Mail: 5.5
RUCK: 5.5
13. George Kruis - 5.75/10
The Rugby Paper: 6
Guardian: 5
Mail: 6
RUCK: 6
12. Mike Brown - 5.9/10
The Rugby Paper: 5
Guardian: 6
Mail: 6.5
RUCK: 6
10=. Elliot Daly - 6/10
The Rugby Paper: 6
Guardian: 5
Mail: 6.5
RUCK: 6.5
10=. Dylan Hartley - 6/10
The Rugby Paper: 5
Guardian: 6
Mail: 6.5
RUCK: 6.5
8=. Dan Cole - 6.2/10
The Rugby Paper: 5.5
Guardian: 6
Mail: 6.5
RUCK: 6.5
8=. Chris Robshaw - 6.2/10
The Rugby Paper: 6
Guardian: 6
Mail: 6.5
RUCK: 6
7. Ben Youngs - 6.3/10
The Rugby Paper: 6
Guardian: 6
Mail: 6.5
RUCK: 6.5
6. Anthony Watson - 6.4/10
The Rugby Paper: 5.5
Guardian: 7
Mail: 6.5
RUCK: 6.5
5. George Ford - 6.5/10
The Rugby Paper: 6.5
Guardian: 6
Mail: 7
RUCK: 6.5
4. Courtney Lawes - 6.7/10
The Rugby Paper: 6.5
Guardian: 7
Mail: 6.5
RUCK: 6.5
3. Sam Underhill - 7.7/10
The Rugby Paper: 6
Guardian: 8
Mail: 8
RUCK: 8.5
2. Nathan Hughes - 7.8/10
The Rugby Paper: 7
Guardian: 7
Mail: 8.5
RUCK: 8.5
1. Mako Vunipola 8/10
The Rugby Paper: 8
Guardian: 8
Mail: 8
RUCK: 8
MORE STORIES:
TRENDING
LATEST NEWS
LATEST COMMENTS
- Jordie Barrett over Damian de Allende is far from being correct. The hype around Dupont is also overreaching, he's probably 4th in the world and has been since the 2023 WC. He also avoids certain matchups which is strange. The rest of the list is pretty good apart from minor subjective biases.JasonMarlow16-09-2026
Loading