"Leader of men" - England legend Martin Johnson named best rugby captain of all-time - Ruck

“Leader of men” – England legend Martin Johnson named best rugby captain of all-time

As the helm of a team, the role of a captain stands as a paramount honor intertwined with profound responsibilities. It is a mantle reserved exclusively for individuals who embody leadership qualities and set a compelling example for their peers.

Indeed, the influence of a remarkable captain can be the fulcrum upon which a team pivots, determining whether they languish in mediocrity or soar to dominance.

In the annals of the game, we have borne witness to the comings and goings of captains, each etching their own unique chapter. Some have scripted tales of triumph, while others have faced a more challenging narrative, and only a select few have left an indelible imprint on the sport’s history.

In the realm of international rugby, spanning countless years, a constellation of iconic captains has graced the stage. These luminaries not only etched their names into the annals of their respective clubs but also ascended to legendary status.

Keeping this rich tapestry in mind, a question emerges: who deserves the mantle of the greatest rugby captain of all time? The readers of RUCK have been tasked with this weighty decision, and in their discerning judgment, England’s celebrated legend, Martin Johnson, stands tall as the pinnacle of leadership excellence.

Get your tickets for the 2024 Six Nations at viagogo, the world’s leading ticket marketplace.


The best rugby captains should have the following qualities:

  • A great player
  • Inspire confidence in their team
  • Takes responsibility 
  • Lead by example
  • Great sportsmanship 
  • Tactical knowhow 
  • Excellent communicator 
  • Emotional discipline 

Greatest Ever Rugby Captains: Top 20

20. Phillipe Saint-Andre (France) – A dynamic winger turned coach, Saint-Andre’s speed and flair graced French rugby. His coaching prowess took him from player to national team leader, shaping the future of French rugby.

19. Lawrence Dallaglio (England) – A fearless back-row giant, Dallaglio captained England to Rugby World Cup glory in 2003. His powerful runs and tireless work ethic defined English rugby.

18. Sergio Parisse (Italy) – Italy’s rugby icon, Parisse’s leadership and skill at number 8 made him a legend. His dedication elevated Italian rugby on the world stage.

17. John Dawes (Wales) – A Welsh rugby hero, Dawes captained the British and Irish Lions to a historic series win against New Zealand in 1971, showcasing his tactical brilliance.

16. Will Carling (England) – Carling’s charisma and leadership made him an iconic England captain. His center partnership with Jeremy Guscott was legendary.