Skip to content

Every Nations Championship referee graded in Round 6 – Hollie Davidson endures nightmare

Rugby News
Nations Championship referees graded round 6
Six referees, six very different afternoons and another weekend when rugby's officials found themselves under the microscope.
England demolished New Zealand, Ireland stunned South Africa and Scotland ran riot against Japan.
But the officials had their own battles to fight.
Hollie Davidson endured a nightmare finish in Paris, Nic Berry faced questions at Twickenham and Ben O'Keeffe made a controversial call at Murrayfield.
Meanwhile, one referee earned an impressive A−.
Here are RUCK's grades for all six officials from Round 6 of the Nations Championship.
These grades are RUCK's editorial opinion, based on key decisions and match management rather than an official World Rugby assessment.

Christophe Ridley – Ireland 20–17 South Africa

Grade: A−
The standout performance of the weekend.
Ridley had a difficult assignment in Dublin, particularly with Rassie Erasmus serving a six-match suspension following his criticism of match officials.
But the Englishman looked comfortable handling a fiercely physical encounter.
His biggest test came in the closing stages, when Dan Sheehan was penalised for a dangerous clear-out on Marco van Staden.
Moments later, Van Staden was involved in another dangerous clear-out, making contact with Tadhg Beirne's head and neck area.
Both incidents required disciplinary decisions, with Van Staden's sanction upgraded to red following review.
Ridley also had to establish which offence came first, with South Africa awarded the penalty.
It was a complicated sequence, but the Englishman remained composed under pressure.
An impressive display in one of the weekend's toughest fixtures.

Nic Berry – England 37–12 New Zealand

Grade: B−
Berry had a decent afternoon overall, but one decision left All Blacks supporters scratching their heads.
The Australian official was involved in a disputed breakdown call shortly before Ben Earl crossed for England's third try.
New Zealand appeared to have a case for a penalty, but Berry judged that they had already won possession.
England subsequently received a scrum in a dangerous position and made the most of it.
It was a significant moment, particularly with the contest still alive.
However, blaming Berry for New Zealand's record 25-point defeat would be a stretch.
England were comfortably the better side.
One questionable call takes some shine off an otherwise reasonable performance.

Ben O'Keeffe – Scotland 67–5 Japan

Grade: B
O'Keeffe had a relatively straightforward afternoon as Scotland ran in 11 tries at Murrayfield.
But there was still one decision that raised eyebrows.
Japan replacement Mamoru Harada was shown a yellow card for a hip-drop tackle, much to Eddie Jones's frustration.
The former England boss argued that the incident was unintentional and that Harada had released the player rather than falling onto his legs.
Jones also questioned whether rugby was becoming too quick to reduce teams to 14 or 13 players.
However, intent isn't the only consideration when assessing dangerous play. The nature of the tackle and the risk to the opponent also matter.
O'Keeffe had a decision to make, and Jones's disagreement alone doesn't make it the wrong one.
A solid afternoon overall.

Andrew Brace – Italy 16–21 Fiji

Grade: B
Brace oversaw one of the closest matches of the weekend as Fiji claimed a narrow victory in Udine.
Italy led at half-time but couldn't hold off the visitors.
The result left Azzurri coach Gonzalo Quesada frustrated, with the Argentine questioning two refereeing decisions afterwards.
However, he stopped short of blaming the officials for the defeat.
Without clear evidence that Brace made a significant error, marking him down heavily would be unfair.
A reasonable performance in a tight contest.

Hollie Davidson – France 45–17 Argentina

Grade: B−
If anyone deserved a quiet evening after this one, it was Hollie Davidson.
The Scottish referee endured a nightmare finish in Paris as a bizarre five-minute delay brought the match to a standstill.
Argentina's front-row problems, head injury assessments and the laws surrounding uncontested scrums created an almighty headache.
Los Pumas were down to 13 players, with Julian Montoya serving a yellow card and Mayco Vivas having received a red.
Davidson initially called for an uncontested scrum before officials had to establish which Argentina players were eligible to return.
Joe Sclavi's departure for a head injury assessment proved crucial.
There was further confusion when Guido Petti came onto the pitch, only to be sent back off while the officials worked through the situation.
It was a complete mess.
But blaming Davidson for the entire mess would be unfair. Argentina's front-row problems created an unusually complicated situation, and the officiating team eventually worked through it.
The circumstances were unusually complicated, and the officials eventually reached the correct conclusion.
As we explained in our report on the five-minute stoppage, Davidson ultimately worked through the situation.
Could the whole thing have been handled more smoothly? Absolutely.
But rushing into the wrong decision would have been far worse.
A nightmare finish, certainly. A nightmare refereeing performance? Not quite.

Luc Ramos – Wales 26–29 Australia

Grade: D
Ramos had a tight contest to manage in Cardiff as Australia edged Wales by just three points.
But one controversial incident cast a huge shadow over the French official's performance.
Wallabies prop Taniela Tupou appeared to throw a punch during an altercation with a Wales player, yet escaped punishment.
Welsh supporters were furious, particularly with the apparent lack of intervention from the TMO.
One fan wrote: "I hope Tupou gets cited for that punch. Couldn't believe the TMO didn't even take a look at it."
Another added: "Tupou should have been off the field for his punch when he scored his try for Australia. Why didn't TMO intervene??"
The controversy was made worse by Tupou going on to score a try in a match Australia won by just three points.
Had the incident been judged worthy of a red card, the Wallabies could have been reduced to 14 players.
While Ramos managed much of the contest reasonably well, such a potentially match-changing incident cannot be ignored.
However, a potentially costly oversight from the officiating team overshadowed an otherwise reasonable display. The TMO must share responsibility, but Ramos cannot escape criticism when an apparent act of foul play goes unpunished in such a close contest.

RUCK's referee of the round

Christophe Ridley takes the honours after his impressive performance in Dublin.
The Englishman handled a difficult encounter with authority and earns the weekend's only A−.
Berry and Davidson had more awkward moments, although for very different reasons.
And after another weekend of debate, one thing is clear.
Being a Test referee remains one of the toughest jobs in rugby.
loading

LATEST COMMENTS

Loading