England prop Joe Marler has weighed in on a debate analysing the quality of punditry during the 2022 Six Nations across BBC and ITV.
The controversial article, written by up-and-coming rugby scribe Ben Nurse, suggests “The pundits are boring, the commentators are frazzled, and neither of them really know anything about rugby”.
Despite the article receiving a mixed reception, Marler has backed up the writer by tweeting: "Like staring at paint becoming unwettened……."
BBC and ITV Six Nations pundits ranked by fan popularity
#16. Andy Nicol (Scotland) - BBC
Wales Online: "Can be as dank and drizzly as the weather north of the border. At times even the ITV adverts can offer a little bit more enjoyment than a piece of half-time analysis on the BBC from the 23-times capped former Dark Blue scrum-half."
#15. Jonathan Davies (Wales) - BBC
#14.Sir Clive Woodward (England) - ITV
Wales Online: "You get the sense England’s 2003 World Cup-winning coach is more suited to the column inches of a newspaper that the TV airwaves. Especially on ITV where due to the commitment to constant commercial breaks there’s very little time to go into in-depth analysis which was Woodward’s forte when coaching the Red Rose."
#13. Chris Paterson (Scotland) - BBC
#12. Rory Best (Ireland) - ITV
#11. Lawrence Dallaglio (England) - ITV
#10. Gareth Thomas (Wales) ITV
#9. Benjamin Kayser (France) - ITV
#8. Dylan Hartley (England) - BBC
#7. John Barclay (Scotland) - BBC
#6. Sir Ian McGeechan (Scotland) - ITV
Wales Online: "Technically brilliant with the way he breaks down a half of rugby and gives a fascinating insight into back division moves. What more would you expect from a Lions coaching legend."
#5. Jonny Wilkinson (England) - ITV
#4. Martin Johnson (England) - BBC
#3. Maggie Alphonsi (England) - ITV
#2. Brian O'Driscoll (Ireland) - ITV
Wales Online: "The Irish rugby legend has taken to punditry like he did to the oval-ball game and is among a rare breed indeed."
#1.Sam Warburton (Wales) -BBC
The BBC pulled off a bit of a coup signing up the former Lions and Wales skipper when his career came to an end with injury. He's been a revelation.
“The pundits are boring, the commentators are frazzled, and neither of them really know anything about rugby”
The Six Nations soap opera was tedious for rugby fans this year. Are we asking too much for commentators who know the player’s names?
thematchreport.co.uk/2022/03/23/why…
Clive Woodward saying he hasn’t seen Ollie Lawrence play for Worcester is *outrageous*. Imagine a pundit on an England match at the Euros this year saying he hasn’t seen a player at a lower-table Premier League club play at all.
They’re supposed to be experts.
Lawrence Dallaglio is the perfect example of a pundit who has educated himself on the laws, the framework on the sanctions over the last couple of years and, consequently, adds so much to the analysis.
Dylan Hartley was fantastic as a pundit on the weekend.
Informed, amusing and articulate.
And incredibly self depricating.
Really hope we see more of him.
Sam Warburton is the best rugby pundit on TV, by a country mile.
Insightful, articulate, and always fascinating to listen to, he makes the atrocious BT Sport pundits look like complete amateurs. #WALvFRA#GuinnessSixNations 🏉